Metacrisis Action Lab #6

The Economics of Trust

In 1892 immigrants on the Lower East Side pooled $95. That fund has lent over $500 million since, interest free, 99% repaid, and Rob Hurwich spent six years building the kind ten people can start.

November 10, 2026 · Lightning Lofts, Brooklyn, NY

☞ Download the deck☞ See the event on Luma☞ Read the transcript
Audio briefingThe lab in 9 min

Made by AI from the write-up on this page, so the room reaches people who could not be in it. Not a podcast episode.

The Economics of Trust — Metacrisis Action Lab #6

$95

pooled on the Lower East Side in 1892. The Hebrew Free Loan Society has lent over $500 million interest free since, to more than 900,000 borrowers, and says 99% comes back

97%

of the money in circulation in the UK is bank deposits, which the Bank of England says are mostly created when commercial banks make loans

1967

the year ten cooperatives in Barquisimeto started Cecosesola with a funeral service. It now runs a hospital and supplies groceries to about 100,000 families

The back of the room watching a slide that reads We have everything we need, we just can't coordinate to share it, with the speaker out of focus on the stage beyond and two attendees silhouetted in the foreground.

In Action Lab #6, Dear Crisis community member Rob Hurwich came to teach us how to pool money with people we know. He is the Tech Director at Catalist, and has spent six years building community economies. He challenged the assumption that we lack the resources to look after each other. We have the resources. We simply lack the coordination.

Money is what moves resources between strangers, and money is trust. Rather than put our trust in banks, corporations and nation states, we can begin divesting from the extractive system and take control of our own resources.

This is what happened.

Snapshots from the Evening

Part 1 · Who sits in the middle

Rob Hurwich

Tech Director, Catalist · founder, Holistic Systems Cooperative

Rob Hurwich on the low stage, seated on a leather pouf with a microphone and gesturing with his free hand, under string lights. The title slide behind him reads The Economics of Trust, Who sits in the middle, beside a ring of pink dots.

California in the 1930s has fields rotting with fruit and vegetables and few farmers with money to pay harvesters. The crops are there. The people willing to work are there. What is missing is the thing that moves value between them. Rob Hurwich: "We have all of the resources that we need in order to take care of ourselves, take care of the planet, and all beings on it. But we're just not able to coordinate making that happen." Reading the gap as a mechanism rather than a villain is what makes it something a group can act on.

An economy is how value moves to meet needs. Two of the three routes are top-down: markets, through buying and selling, and the state, through taxes and services. The third is each other, through sharing, swapping and pooling. A group cannot start a market or a state. It can start the third one this month, which is where the night's whole argument sits.

Trust has to sit somewhere whenever value moves between strangers. We put ours in banks and the state because that is easy and efficient, and the cost is that we are beholden to them. The alternative is slower and closer: a group you know and run, where the terms are yours. Neither is free of trust. One of them charges rent on it.

The middle decides four things: who gets money, what counts as money, who may compete, and who collects interest. The Bank of England's own 2014 account of money creation puts bank deposits at 97% of the money in circulation and says those deposits are mostly created when commercial banks make loans. The institution naming the figure is the one at the centre of it.

  • Quarterly Bulletin 2014 Q1, "Money creation in the modern economy", by Michael McLeay, Amar Radia and Ryland Thomas. The 97% is the deposit share of broad money as of December 2013; the Bank's current explainer gives 96%.

A hundred dollars goes out and a hundred and ten has to come back. Profit is not optional inside that arrangement, so the system needs more every year than it needed last year. What it produces then feeds it: wealth disparity, because money makes money; financialization, where returns beat making things; and scarcity for anyone without money, which is artificial rather than physical.

Pooling joins resources in a shared pot. Circulation keeps value moving through exchange. Distribution sends it to whoever needs it. Lending a car is pooling, swapping childsitting is circulation, a Buy Nothing group is distribution. None of this replaces the mainstream economy; it runs parallel to it, from the bottom up, which is what makes it available without anyone's permission.

Of the three, pooling asks the least. A group of about ten people each put in a set amount, and the pot does what no member could alone. Non-monetary exchange has to settle what an hour of childcare is worth against an hour of plumbing before it can move; a shared pot does not. Rob's design pattern is to start simple and grow from there, because this is a practice most people have never done.

Rotating hands the whole pot to one member each round. Savings gets you your own money back. Lending advances it and takes repayment. Risk pays whoever is hit. Buying gets a better price together. Asset shares what the pool owns. Grant lets the group pick who receives. Income-sharing sends more to whoever has less. Most real pools stack two or three.

Three people dream up the Asheville Tool Library in 2013, spend about two and a half years raising money, and open in 2016. It now lends more than 3,700 tools to over a thousand members. When Hurricane Helene floods western North Carolina in September 2024 the library is eight years old, and its building becomes a relief hub rather than something anyone has to invent that week. Brooklyn's Greenpoint library lends more than 130 tools on the same principle.

  • Helene's flooding reached Asheville in the early hours of 27 September 2024. The library's own staff are modest about its role: a solar generator the day after, then a hub at Smith Mill Works, and chainsaw safety classes run in its space by the Skills Academy for Women.

The Hebrew Free Loan Society starts on New York's Lower East Side in 1892 with ninety-five dollars pooled by immigrants, lending interest free from as little as fifty cents. It has since lent more than five hundred million dollars to over nine hundred thousand borrowers and reports ninety-nine percent repaid. More than fifty free loan societies now operate across North America and beyond, each started by its own community, and none is a branch of another.

  • The New York society is non-sectarian and lends on income and residence. Other agencies in the association set their own rules, so "you do not have to be Jewish" is true of New York and not of the movement.
  • The body is the International Association of Jewish Free Loans, whose directory lists 56 agencies.

A crew doing one member's big job each round until everyone has had a turn is meitheal in Ireland, dugnad in Norway, mweria in Kenya, gotong royong in Indonesia, bayanihan in the Philippines, minga in the Andes, gadugi among the Cherokee, and a barn raising in the United States. The money version is a susu or sou-sou in West Africa and among Caribbean New Yorkers, a pardner in Jamaica, a tanda in Latin America, a stokvel in South Africa. Brooklyn has run susus since at least the 1980s.

  • The academic term is a rotating savings and credit association, or ROSCA, defined by Shirley Ardener in 1964. "Found in every culture" is not supportable: no study shows that. Documented on every inhabited continent is.

People pool to get through hard times, to build something together, to belong and celebrate, and to live their values. Only the first is survival. A group that forms on need alone empties when the need passes, which is the pattern the Depression leaves behind. Two things pooling returns either way: resilience, which is being less at the mercy of whoever sits in the middle, and agency, which is room to do the work you want rather than only the work you have to.

More than three hundred thousand Americans are in self-help cooperatives by 1932, and they are gone once federal relief pays cash. Two survivors show the two ways through. Switzerland's WIR runs from 1934 to now because the need never leaves: small firms still struggle to get credit. Cecosesola in Venezuela runs from 1967 on culture instead, with no manager, no supervisor and no board, about three hundred joint meetings a year, and a flat refusal to call itself a model.

  • Ten cooperatives founded Cecosesola for a funeral service the insurance law made hard for any single cooperative to run. It now holds a health centre with two operating rooms and twenty beds at about half private prices, and twenty market spaces supplying groceries to roughly a hundred thousand families. Right Livelihood Award, 2022.
  • Rob's conclusion from the research: the mechanics matter less than the culture of trust, and a group with that culture can absorb people who never cared about systems change.

Of twenty-eight answers, seventeen want a shared project, space or tool. Twenty-one would put in money and the other seven time or skills. Twenty would start at fifty dollars a month or less. On what would make them trust a group with money: history between the members, agreement on where it goes, something written down, and at least two people responsible for the accounting.

Act II · The proposals

Five pools, written down

Each group takes one purpose off the wall, picks the mechanisms that fit the trust, proximity and admin it actually has, then writes its agreements and tests them against scenario cards. What follows is each proposal as it stands: what it pools, what you put in, what you can draw, and who decides.

A land and home trust on twelve to twenty acres, drawn as a circle: the land is the whole pie, the middle is communal, and the slices around it are privately owned with a house at the back of each.

Taking it forward: Katherine right away, in Woodstock. Jessica Es on a five-year plan, Emil Moldovan on a fifteen-year plan

What it pools

Savings toward a purchase, and the services a group buys once instead of five times: one real estate agent, one lawyer between them. Members with more administrative capacity than money trade work for a share. The limit is named up front, since nobody accepts sweat equity against a million and a half.

How it is financed

About a hundred and fifty thousand dollars a person through banks. The alternative is to buy the land first and run a susu to build the houses one at a time, which puts everyone on a construction site for a decade before the last one is up.

Who is in

By consensus. The members who already live in a seventeen-room house hold that this is the term deciding every other term.

Before anyone buys

Travel internationally together first. Legal costs are budgeted rather than discovered.

What one member needs now

Acreage, a spring-fed pond or a stream above the neighbours' septic, off-grid, eighty percent food independent, a five-bedroom minimum. Woodstock, for the mountain range between it and the city.

A grant fund for each other's creative projects: ten founding members, fifty dollars a month, one ten-month cycle.

Taking it forward: Kalia ZiZi B.

What you put in

Fifty dollars a month for ten months, and one project that is neither too big nor too tiny. A small immersive theater activation, a weekend retreat.

What you can draw

Five hundred dollars, once, at some point in the cycle. Each month one member pitches and the group votes on who receives next.

Who stewards it

Nobody. A treasurer makes one person responsible for collecting from nine others, which is the part that turns a pool into a chore.

The pay party

The transfer is an event rather than an invoice. The recipient presents, the group asks how it can help, and everyone sends at once.

The group's own warning

The questions outran the answers inside the hour. One member, on the pile of them: this is why we do not do this.

A pod for people who have recently moved to a city, run by people who have recently moved. Four of its five founders arrived in New York within weeks, one of them two days before.

Taking it forward: Ilana Strauss

What it pools

An emergency fund. A pass-it-on gift, where a member receives a living or growing asset and repays by passing its yield to the next. Shared commons with duties, shared services, work trade.

What you can draw

A room. Someone newly arrived stays rent free, cooking and doing the domestic work, while the members who already found work pay the rent.

How you move through it

From helped to helping. Getting established is what qualifies you to take in the next arrival.

Who is in

Not open by default. A dating period first, because it has to work for the people who started it.

Why these founders

Solidarity between the recently displaced is what makes it strong enough to start at all. It works in any city, not only this one.

A fund for the potential nothing else pays for, from a skill-building workshop at one end to a three-month sabbatical at the other.

Taking it forward: Allison Tucker, Christine Lai and Benjamin Von Wong

What you put in

A hundred dollars a month, or time, or something non-monetary, so the pool is not only financial.

What you can draw

A workshop, or three months to find out what you actually want to work on.

What comes back

Whoever learns something teaches it to the group, so the fund grows the group's capacity rather than spending it.

Who is in

Three months at the edges before anyone signs or contributes, then a reflection on both sides, because both parties have to want it. A review at twelve months, since lives change.

How it decides

A bounce format one member already uses, and Fist of Five, so the group decides together and each person's position stays visible.

The entry requirement

You have to be into improv.

A third space the group owns, with paid organizers to build the community around it.

Taking it forward: Abby Stoner

What it pools

Money toward a space, and the spaces and tools members already hold, mapped so the group knows what it can leverage.

What it pays for

Organizers, stipended. Building a community is work, and the proposal pays for it rather than hoping someone volunteers.

Who is in

Fifty-five at the open: five founders who each recruit ten. Everyone in the room gets a referral, and after that anyone can refer anyone.

How you leave

By deciding you are no longer part of it. Codes of conduct rather than an exit process.

How it decides

Elected governance, with people representing different areas, probably volunteer.

What participation buys

At a certain level, a key to the space.

Every proposal answers the same questions. What are we pooling for. Which mechanisms fit us. Who is in, and how do they leave. What can you draw, and when. Who stewards it.

Run it yourself

The pooling kit

Rob's workshop is a card game a group can run without him. A table of three to six lays down a purpose, describes itself with three about-us cards, and sorts the mechanisms into what fits, what could work with a plan and what does not work yet. Then it writes its rules of trust on the canvas and tests them against scenario cards. The deck and the canvas are what a table plays with; the other three sheets are what it reaches for along the way. All five are Rob's, free to copy and adapt under CC BY-SA 4.0.

PDF · 30 pagesCollective Pooling Design CardsThe deck itself, 58 cards to print double-sided, four to a page: a table guide with the rules, 10 purpose cards, nine about-us cards for your trust level, proximity, and admin and legal capacity, 18 mechanism cards in eight colours, nine agreement cards for the rules of trust, and six scenario cards holding 11 stress tests, from a missed payment to the person who keeps the books burning out.Open the PDF ↗PDF · 2 pagesCollective Pooling CanvasThe worksheet each group fills in. Page one is the purpose and the details: the purpose card, the about-us cards you laid down, the mechanisms you chose, and the settings, from how many people to the split between funds. Page two is ten rules of trust, most of them tied to one of Elinor Ostrom's principles, with the three first agreements boxed.Open the PDF ↗PDF · 1 pageHolding the moneySix ways to hold a pool's money, from no pot at all, where each member pays on call, to a lockbox at meetings, one treasurer, a shared account in the group's name, an existing organization, and later the group's own entity. It lists the rules that apply whichever you pick and the legal questions still to check with a lawyer, and suggests starting with no pot for the first few months.Open the PDF ↗PDF · 3 pagesModels and instancesForty real pools to learn from, coloured by the eight kinds of pool: twenty models, such as the sou-sou, the chama and the bread fund, and twenty places people ran them, from the Hebrew Free Loan Society to the Park Slope Food Coop. The ones in New York are marked.Open the PDF ↗PDF · 2 pagesCirculation and exchangeFor a group that wants value to keep moving rather than build up a pot: mutual credit, time banks, community currencies, money that loses value when held, commitment pooling and personal currencies, each with real examples and a cautionary case, and a note on what tokens are and are not.Open the PDF ↗

Reference

The cheat sheet

The reference tables from the session, rebuilt so you can come back to them. Tap one to open it; scroll sideways on a phone.

KindHow it works
RotatingEveryone pays in and each round one member takes the whole pot
SavingsSave together, and get your own money back
LendingBorrow from the pot when you need it, then repay
RiskEveryone pays in; whoever is hit gets help
BuyingBuy together for a better price than any member would get
AssetThe pool owns something and members share the use of it
GrantThe group decides together who receives a grant
Income-sharingMore flows to whoever has less
NameWhereWhat rotates
MeithealIrelandLabour: the crew does one member's big job each round
DugnadNorwayLabour
MweriaKenyaLabour
Gotong royongIndonesiaLabour
Bayanihanthe PhilippinesLabour
Minga and aynithe AndesLabour
GadugiCherokeeLabour
Barn raising, or frolicthe United States and the AmishLabour
Susu, or sou-souWest Africa and Caribbean BrooklynMoney: each round one member takes the hand
PardnerJamaicaMoney
TandaLatin AmericaMoney
StokvelSouth AfricaMoney

The academic term for the money version is a rotating savings and credit association, or ROSCA, defined by Shirley Ardener in 1964. Harlem's 1920s rent parties are often filed here and do not belong: the host charged a quarter at the door, sold food and drink, and kept that month's takings. There was no membership and no obligation to host in return. The rent gap behind them is real and documented: a 1924 National Urban League study found Black renters paying forty to sixty percent more than white tenants for the same class of apartment.

CaseStartedWhat happened
US self-help cooperatives1931 to 1933More than 300,000 members by 1932. Federal relief from mid-1933 tied the groups to rules that limited their cash sales and removed the backing for their scrip, and they faded. There was no federal effort to suppress them
WIR, Switzerland1934Still running, because the need never went away: small firms still struggle to get credit
Cecosesola, Venezuela1967Still running on culture rather than structure. No manager, no supervisor, no board, about 300 joint meetings a year, a Right Livelihood Award in 2022, and a refusal to describe itself as a model

From the room

“I just want to say the cards are awesome. It made it so much faster to get through and to see the scope and scale.”

“I totally disagree. I found the cards to be really distracting, and they actually prevented us from getting to the practical points, and too much arguing over the nuances of the semantics.”

“There were so many questions here that I wouldn't have thought to ask had I not had access to these cards.”

“It would have been helpful to just decide on the idea first. We decided exactly what the idea was that we wanted to do, and then got into the nitty gritty.”

“It definitely highlighted that it's not as easy as just collect your money.”

Go deeper

Resources & where to plug in

☞ All recaps (Salons & Action Labs)