Metacrisis Action Lab #6 · Cleaned Transcript
November 10, 2026 · Lightning Lofts, Brooklyn, NY
A cleaned and condensed transcript: filler trimmed, crosstalk smoothed, the shape of the night kept intact. It is not verbatim. Rob Hurwich and Ben are named; attendees who spoke from the room are not. Where a figure said aloud differed from the slide or from the primary source, the checked version is used.
Download as .txtBen · I love waiting for a room to get quiet. There is something fun about that silence rolling in, and you can almost feel the peace entering the room as everyone gets ready. Thank you all for choosing to spend your Tuesday evening being good students of the world. I am sure you are here for different reasons, but collectively you are interested in cooperatives.
Ben · This is a seventeen-room community house across two floors, and this is our living room. I have lived here three years, and four of us who live here are in the room tonight. There are three bathrooms. Action labs are the smaller format, capped at thirty, and this is our home, so if you see something lying around, bring it forward. If you have a drink, finish it, because half-finished drinks get knocked over.
Ben · The agreements we hold space by: keep it brief if you are going to ask a question or make a statement. We sometimes have disagreements in this crowd, and you do not need to resolve them or agree. Notice it, hold onto it, and see where your curiosity takes you. More than three quarters of the room has been to a salon or a lab before, so if you see someone new, go make a friend. The knowledge is the excuse to bring like-minded people together. Getting to know each other is the opportunity.
Ben · The community is Dear Crisis. Fourteen hundred people have come through seventy-two events over eighteen months. Salons, action labs, hackathons, creative workshops, and we are hoping to add field trips. It started as a response to something about New York: we spend our time going out and distracting ourselves with the amazing things this city offers, then we come home, turn on the news, and feel lonely and alone. What if we reversed that? What if we bring the ideas to the front, sit together in the discomfort, and turn disempowerment into activation. Which makes us ask the same question every time. We have this information. Now what do we want to do about it, and how do we do it together?
Ben · Rob is our featured guest, and he does not even live in New York City. He has been a frequent attendee of these salons, and a few weeks ago, talking about cooperative economics and collective capital, I found out he is a complete nerd about this. So I said you have to lead a thing. My dream is that pods come out of this workshop and go and run with something, because the best way to learn is by doing it with a couple of other people who keep you accountable. No pressure. He is volunteering his time, and this is an entirely volunteer-run community.
Rob Hurwich · The most exciting thing for me is the implementation of these alternative or complementary economic models. I have worked specifically on this for six years, on the research, the design and the prototypes. The most valuable thing is people who are willing to actually participate, because you can design things all day long and build apps for them, and unless people bring their agency, they just sit there.
Rob Hurwich · Another way to introduce myself is the core question of my life. On Earth we have all of the resources we need in order to take care of ourselves, take care of the planet, and all beings on it. But we are not able to coordinate making that happen. That is a ridiculous situation. A lot of it is the systems and mechanisms in place.
The slide behind him quoted California in the 1930s: fields rotting with tons of fruit and vegetables, and few farmers with money to pay harvesters.
Rob Hurwich · In the Great Depression there were plenty of crops on the ground to be harvested and plenty of people willing to do the work, and no money to pay anybody. It was not a lack of value or of desire. It was a lack of currency.
Rob Hurwich · One way to talk about an economy is as how value moves to meet our needs. Right now we have large-scale top-down mechanisms, markets and nation states. Collective pooling is bottom-up, and that is where the empowerment is, because we can just do it.
Rob Hurwich · Trust has to happen somewhere whenever value is flowing. What we have done is outsource trust to the system. There are reasons for that. Money is an easy tool, and efficient. But there are costs, because then we are beholden to that system to hold the trust. The flip is: what if we placed that trust in each other instead? Slower and closer, and we set the terms.
Rob Hurwich · The sentence on this slide is the one that encapsulates it. Whoever holds our trust sits in the middle and sets the terms. The middle decides who gets money, what counts as money, who may compete, and who collects interest.
On money creation, the slide cited the Bank of England's 2014 Quarterly Bulletin: bank deposits are 97% of the money in circulation, and are mostly created by commercial banks when they make loans.
Rob Hurwich · Borrowed money has to come back bigger. A hundred goes out, a hundred and ten has to come back, so profit is not optional and the system needs more every year. What that produces feeds itself: wealth disparity, financialization, which if you think about it is wild, money made from money with no actual value behind it, and scarcity for anyone without money.
Rob Hurwich · Sometimes this feels frustrating and I get angry at the powers that be, and that is fair. But if I can look at it as systems and mechanisms, it is relieving, because it demystifies it. These are systems operating a certain way. So what are the systems we can incorporate that operate a different way? Economics holds the power over our basic survival needs, and when you have to do certain things to survive, that is where a culture gets reinforced that we did not choose.
Everyone answers questions to buy a ticket, and the answers went up before the exercise. Of twenty-eight responses, seventeen wanted a shared project, space or tool. Twenty-one would put in money and the other seven would put in time or skills. Twenty would start at fifty dollars a month or less.
Asked what would make them trust a group with their money, the room had written: that trust was already built; that everyone agreed where it was going; that there was history between us, a written agreement, and at least two people responsible for the admin and accounting; and that the members were genuine friends with consistent touch points, like monthly dinners.
Rob Hurwich · Trust comes from knowing each other and agreeing where the money goes. That makes sense.
Rob Hurwich · Complementary economies are bottom-up systems meant to run parallel to the current one, at least for now. It is not meant to take over, though the further you march along the more that becomes possible. Value flows three ways: pooling, which joins things together within a group; circulation, which is exchange of goods and services; and distribution, which moves resources from where there is more to where they are needed. We start with pooling because it is simpler than non-monetary exchange of services. We have to relearn what our ancestors already knew, so start simple is a good design pattern.
Rob Hurwich · If a slice of pizza costs five dollars and I have four, I cannot get the pizza. If I go in with my four dollars and three other people, we buy a whole pizza. Now you have two slices and I have two slices.
Eight kinds of pool went up, in the colours of the cards the room would use later: rotating, savings, lending, risk, buying, asset, grant and income-sharing. Then the specific cases.
Rob Hurwich · A tool library is the easy one to picture. Douglas Rushkoff was here the other night talking about the power drill you buy, use for fifteen minutes in its whole life, and throw in the trash.
The Asheville Tool Library in North Carolina was dreamed up by three people in 2013, opened its first location in 2016, and now holds more than 3,700 tools for over a thousand members. When Hurricane Helene flooded western North Carolina in September 2024 it had been operating eight years, and its space became a relief hub. Brooklyn's Greenpoint library lends more than 130 tools.
Rob Hurwich · The point is to prepare for the storm before it comes rather than have to scramble.
The Hebrew Free Loan Society was founded on New York's Lower East Side in 1892 by immigrants who pooled ninety-five dollars. It has lent more than five hundred million dollars interest free to over nine hundred thousand borrowers, from loans as small as fifty cents, and reports ninety-nine percent repaid. There are more than fifty free loan societies across North America and beyond, and none of them is a branch of another.
Rob Hurwich · When I was a senior in college as a film major I needed money for my final film and did not have it. I went to a Jewish free loan society and got a loan, and I was able to make it.
Did you have to be Jewish?
Rob Hurwich · In most of these cases, no. Though I am Jewish, so I do not remember whether it helped.
Is there research on why people pay these back? That is a higher payback rate than most banks get. You could theorize that people care about each other's wellbeing, but what specifically causes it?
Rob Hurwich · It is an interesting question, and the same thing shows up with microloans and microgrants. I do not know the answer from memory. My sense is that it is community-based, so you know who it is, and there is accountability.
With microgrants you apply as a group, and if one person in the group does not pay back, the group cannot get the next one. So the group dynamics create the accountability.
And in a lot of countries the loans are given out by community leaders, a village leader, who already has that relationship.
Rob Hurwich · That speaks to it being more local in scale, with the greater accountability and trust that brings.
Then the patterns that recur everywhere. A rotating work party, known in the United States as a barn raising, is documented across the world under different names: meitheal in Ireland, dugnad in Norway, mweria in Kenya, gotong royong in Indonesia, bayanihan in the Philippines, minga in the Andes, gadugi among the Cherokee, yui in Japan. A rotating savings pool is called a susu or sou-sou in West Africa and among Caribbean New Yorkers, who have run them in Brooklyn since at least the 1980s, and a pardner in Jamaica, a tanda in Latin America, a chama in Kenya, a hui in Chinese communities, a stokvel in South Africa. Each round, one member takes the hand.
Harlem's house-rent parties in the 1920s were the local version of raising rent money through a crowd: a quarter at the door, music and food, and the night's takings went to that month's rent. The rent gap behind them was documented at the time. A 1924 National Urban League study found Black renters paying forty to sixty percent more than white tenants for the same class of apartment.
Rob Hurwich · The most interesting question for me is why. Why would we do this? I do not want to make assumptions, but I assume we are not doing it because we are in dire need for our basic survival.
Not yet.
Rob Hurwich · Not yet. Who knows what tomorrow brings. A lot of these things came out of sheer survival, getting through hard times. But there are other reasons, and tapping into those is helpful as we go along. On the systemic level it is preparing for the storms, because more crises are coming, and the more we practise the more resilience we build. The flip side of the same coin is agency: the more we provide for our own needs, the less power the systems have over us, which means more choice. And it is systems change, because as we provide for our needs we are divesting from the extractive system and putting that energy into collaborative ones.
Rob Hurwich · When I was researching the Great Depression, a lot of these community-based models flourished. What was interesting was that as the New Deal put more currency back into society, most of them died away. The majority of people had thought of them as a stopgap. They thought the system was generally okay enough. Then there was a smaller subset who were really trying to create something new.
The slide gave the figures. More than three hundred thousand Americans were in self-help cooperatives by 1932, and they were gone once relief jobs paid cash. Two survivors: Switzerland's WIR, running since 1934, because small firms still struggle to get credit; and Cecosesola in Venezuela, since 1967, which holds about three hundred joint meetings a year plus a weekly gathering in each cooperative, and says it does not have a model.
Rob Hurwich · The culture is really important. It is not just the mechanics. In fact the mechanics are less important than developing the culture of trust. If you develop that culture and anchor it, then people who come in who are not as interested in the metacrisis or in systems change can fold into it more easily.
Rob Hurwich · Take a minute. What would be easier in your life if you knew you had ten people who, no matter what, had your back?
Leaving the house. Seriously.
Imagine if we rotated every day and cleaned a different person's house for an hour. Done. I am so bad at motivating myself to clean.
Film equipment. It is so expensive to have all the equipment you need, but if you get ten filmmakers all contributing something, you could get a couple of cameras and a set of equipment.
Ben · Something divergent on that. It is not ten people where nine of them are your slaves and you receive all the benefits. It means you now have nine other people you are beholden to. It is cool in theory, and then when are you going to show up, and how many hours of your own time are going back the other direction?
Rob Hurwich · We are always going to be beholden to something or someone. So we choose.
I can speak to that. My child was in the hospital a couple of years ago, and one family in particular went grocery shopping for us, bought gift cards for food, took care of so many things. Their family just lost their home in a fire last week. I got to be part of supporting them. They live on the other side of the world and I cannot go and do those things for them, but I could put money into a GoFundMe and share it around as many communities as possible. I did not feel bad or beholden. I just felt like I wish I could do more.
There are so many ways to pool. You could be beholden time-wise if time is what you invest. But if you are sharing tools you just pass the tool around, and that does not take much. And the things that do require a lot from us are the ones where the benefit is so clear that you would want to.
There is also chronic support versus acute support. Seventeen people in a house, everyone using my tools all the time, is chronic, and chronic feels harder than acute. Acute is: you are going through an extraordinary time, let us all come together. So time may be skewed to acute, and other things to chronic.
I love the rotating idea, where if you have ten, everybody gets their turn. And not just in scarcity. Imagine each person got a day where you lay out what your dreams are, and everybody focuses on that person and helps draw out who their best version could be. One person a month, for ten months. It is like an extra birthday.
The story I heard was families coming to the US for the first time pooling their money so one family could buy a house, and then that house becomes the leverage for the next family to buy theirs. It created the capital to game the system so the whole family unit had homes. I keep thinking about that at scale. Do we have social security to think about in the future, and can we actually build that future ourselves?
Something like security assumes some of the group will need things at some point and the rest will be relatively secure, so there is always a balance. But in the metacrisis, say everyone in the community has a disaster fund and then they all get hit by the same hurricane. When we talk about these systems theoretically they are so perfect. I would be curious how they have dealt with inconsistency.
Rob Hurwich · You are bringing up a point I like, which is that there is so much history of these. We are at an advantageous place because we can study the actual instances and see where they failed and where they worked. There is so much that is not theoretical.
Mutual insurance is a version of this in its purest form, and there is a lot we can learn from insurance about disproportionate and black swan events.
On aging, there is a village model: a group of older neighbours who decided to age in place and pooled resources for services, which let a lot of people stay in their homes. I have seen it replicated in Philadelphia and a few other places.
The original is Beacon Hill Village in Boston, whose founders began meeting in 1999 and enrolled their first members in 2002. Members pay annual dues that fund a small staff who coordinate help, vet providers and negotiate rates, alongside volunteers who drive and run errands. There are now roughly 350 villages, and the Village to Village Network exists so a new one does not have to build the model from scratch.
Rob Hurwich · The one I came upon not too long ago gives me a lot of hope. Cecosesola, in Venezuela. A group of cooperatives that joined together and started a cooperative funeral service. It is so culture-forward. They say they do not have a model, what they do is education. They have meetings constantly and they joke about how many. And now they have a community hospital, and before that food growing and food stores. To get to the place where you communally own and steward a hospital, and it has been going that long, gives me hope that this is doable.
Ten cooperatives in Barquisimeto founded Cecosesola in 1967, for a funeral service the insurance law made hard for any single cooperative to run. It now operates a health centre with two operating rooms and twenty beds at about half private prices, and twenty market spaces supplying groceries to roughly a hundred thousand families. It has no manager, no supervisor and no board. It received a Right Livelihood Award in 2022.
Ten reasons people pool went up on the wall with a number each: security, spreading big costs, buying power, owning things together, investing in each other, giving outward, caring for each other, evening things out, building future capacity, building collective power. After a few minutes in pairs on what you would want a pool to do and why it matters, everyone walked to their number.
Rob Hurwich · There is a lot of interplay in all of these, and when you get to the cards and see the mechanisms you will see that more. So do not overthink it.
Ben · The chances that you form the pod you will actually buy a house with tonight are small. Maybe higher than in most spaces, still small. This is to get you closer in proximity to a group that might form, and to have a fun conversation. It is not a popularity contest.
Someone asked what evening things out means in practice. Rob described a club in Baltimore where members pledge seven percent of their monthly income, a steward works out the group average, and everyone above it sends money straight to the people below it.
Five groups formed, of three to six people each: owning things together, investing in each other, caring for each other, building future capacity, and building collective power.
Rob Hurwich · There is a framework for how to set these up: mechanisms, models and instances. The mechanisms are the ingredients, so you pull certain ones out of the fridge. The model is the recipe, the tradition that can be repeated, like the susu. The instance is the dish, the one cooked at this restaurant or in your house. Tonight's cards work at the ingredient level.
Rob Hurwich · You start with the purpose, which is your why, the need that is not being met. Then trust, proximity and admin, which are the group variables, the about-us cards. Lay out the mechanisms the purpose allows in the top row, then flip the about-us cards, and some move down. Three rows: good fit, could work with a plan, and not now. So if you want to buy a house together but the time and capacity you have for admin and legal is low, that might not be a good fit.
Rob Hurwich · What you end up with is a collective pooling canvas, like a business model canvas but for pooling. Two breakouts with a shareback between. First the purpose and the details, the mechanisms. Then the agreements, the rules of trust. The actionable part is that your group walks away with a plan, and the idea that this is possible, which demystifies it.
Rob Hurwich · This is not a game you have to play exactly right. The point is to move through how the logistics and mechanics operate and how we could actually do this. So just have fun.
Twenty minutes, then each group reported. Every one of them named the same difficulty first.
We focused on the process of getting the land in the first place over what we will do with it once we have it. Accumulating savings. Shared services, so one real estate agent and one lawyer. Potentially leveraging group collateral, or community free loan funds, or people who have preferential rates, like veterans, to get a loan at better terms. And work trade, if someone in the group has less financial ability but really good admin capability, because this is going to take a lot of admin and legal and paper pushing. But not everyone can work trade all of it. People will not accept your sweat against a million and a half.
Establishing the purpose was the hardest part, at the very beginning. And a lot of what we can do together, a library of things, comes into play only after we buy it. The hardest part will be the legal agreements: how you get out, who is allowed in and out, whether I can give it to my kids, what happens in a divorce.
Similar to that, we each had a slightly different idea of what the purpose was, and depending on which purpose you land on you would choose a different mechanism. You could play this game two ways. You come in with no purpose, look at what is actually in your group, and let the cards tell you what is available to you. Or you come in with a very clear purpose and pick the card that makes sense for it. We were in between those. We liked supporting each other's projects, and the three things that led us there were a group grant fund, a member loan fund, or pass-it-on gift. We landed on the group grant fund.
How much is invested changes the needs. A large investment needs legal contracts. Small and informal enough, and we can keep it simple.
One realization is that four of the five of us arrived here recently, and we all gravitated to this group. One of us moved here two days ago, one came from Paris three days ago, one from Montreal. We got a bit hyper-focused on the mechanism we had already assigned to caring for each other. The ones we were excited about: emergency fund, pass-it-on gift, where a member receives a living or growing asset and repays by passing its offspring or yield to the next member, shared commons with duties, shared services, and work trade.
We talked about geography first, because our trust is spread across the city, so we started with what proximity means to us and what power means to us. We wanted a mechanism that was flexible depending on the month, and we did not want it to be reactive only at times of crisis. We want the abundance, and we want this as a perpetual practice rather than crisis-driven, to keep the culture. So we landed on a group grant fund too, and we were talking through who gets these grants and how we invest in each other's skills. We talked about a sabbatical fund: what would it look like if a group of people said we want you to take a sabbatical and figure out what you want to do for a few months.
We spent our time getting on the same page about how we felt about trust and proximity and admin. We started trying to make sense of the cards and were not quite sure how, so we did some sense-making around that. We were getting close to what it meant to pick a mechanism. We are discerning. We are building power. Sometimes we move slowly.
Rob Hurwich · Once you pick your mechanism, or mechanisms, because they can stack, the next part is the agreements. You go through the agreement cards and discuss them as a group: who makes the decisions, where does the money go. Then there is a set of scenario cards, which are meant to pressure-test the agreements. What if somebody wants out in two months. What if someone does not pay. That is really about creating the group culture and cohesion. If you were doing this over the long term you would want to go through all the agreements, but tonight pick the ones that are resonating and talk about those as long as you need.
Twenty more minutes, with a five-minute extension the room voted for, and a closing instruction from Ben: turn what you have into an invitation, so the other groups can be inspired by it, join it, copy it or adapt it. By the second shareback, all five groups had names.
Stipend organizers from the community to organize both the group itself and the wider community it finds. Identify the shared resources everybody in the community already has, whether that is access to different spaces or starting things like tool libraries across the community, and work out how they could be collectively leveraged. And then specifically something oriented around political or economic power in whatever system this thing finds itself in, and how we could activate it as a community.
On joining: the five of us would each recruit ten people to begin, so we have a collective of fifty-five. Everybody in this room gets a referral, and then anybody could refer anybody, to be very accessible outside of that. Codes of conduct, where there could be ways in which people left, but not some rigorous thing: you could just decide to not be part of it anymore. Elected governance structures, with people representing different areas, probably volunteer-based. And at a certain level of participation you are granted a key, so you get to go into the third space.
Ooh. That is a great incentive.
We are going to invest in each other's potential that normally is not funded, so skill building and potential sabbaticals. This can be as small as a skill-building workshop all the way up to a three-month sabbatical to find a passion of yours. A hundred dollars monthly makes sense as the right healthy amount. Or you could invest time or other non-monetary things, so it is not just financial capital in the pool. And one way this actually builds our collective capacity is that if we go and learn something, we come back and teach each other.
People would be invited in, people that we know, and they would participate from the edges for three months as they get to know the group and the group gets to know them. Then there is a reflection period for both sides, on whether this is something you really want to do, before you sign any agreement or make any initial contributions. Both parties have to like each other. And then people's lives change, so something that can also revolve at twelve months, because you do not want to feel stuck when it is not a good fit.
Some of the values we talked about were generosity and confidence: funding ideas a person is confident about, with group coaching, asking questions of each other and asking for help. For decision-making we have a bounce format and Fist of Five, to make decisions collectively but also honour each person's desires in the space. And to join our group you have to be into improv.
Ben · This is the one I was spending too much time in. In anticipation of collapse you are building social coherence with each other, you are building skills, and you are sharing it back to the community. It did not require that much money to make something really interesting for an entire collective of people.
The idea is that as people move to New York, as you get established, you help people who are just moving to New York. When you first move you do not have a house and you do not have a job. Maybe there is a house where you can go and stay rent free, and you cook and do laundry and all the domestic tasks while you are looking for work. And the people who already got to work are the ones paying rent. Then as you move forward, you help new arrivals adjust.
It is really to create a support system or network specifically built for people who have recently moved, and it can be any city. The idea coming from people who have recently been displaced makes it stronger, because it would have to be started on that solidarity. And making it more solid at that point too, because it has to work for us, so we do not want it just open to anybody. A dating period is something we would want to discuss. Kind of taking how the universe put us together.
Is one of you leading this forward in a more serious manner? · I think all of us were. We are really on board with it.
Our group for investing in each other's projects is seeking ten founding members to invest fifty dollars a month over a ten-month cycle. Each founding member would come in with some creative project, not too big, not too tiny, maybe a small immersive theater activation or a weekend retreat. Over the course of the cycle there are opportunities to pitch your project, and the group will vote towards whose project gets the next infusion. So everybody who joins is going to get a five hundred dollar infusion at some point in the ten months.
The question was who controls the pool of money, and we were like, well, we are all essentially just paying each other, so why do we not just Venmo the person, so we do not have to have someone overhead. And then we thought, that makes it weird, because the person receiving the money is responsible for getting all of the money. So we said let us make a party out of it. After you present your idea and we all ask how we can support you, everyone hits send on their Venmo and says go for it. A monthly pay party.
There were a lot of questions and debates, and it already became exhausting, to the point of me being like, this is why we do not do this.
It might be a lot to try to plan an entire collective pooling project in an hour. · It feels like people got pretty far though.
Two of us have already been forming a creative productivity and accountability group that is gamified, and we will riff on some of this.
We are talking about a land and home trust. The circle is the land. In the middle is the little communal zone where people can go hang out, and the little pieces of pie are privately owned, with the houses built at the back. We are thinking about twelve to twenty acres. Different ways of financing it: accumulating savings, community free loan fund, work trade, collateral and shared services. A number thrown out there was something like a hundred and fifty thousand per person, financed by banks. But somebody also said, what if we bought the land and then we run a susu and build everybody's house one after another, which sounds like a great idea, except you would also be living in a construction zone for ten years. Then again, ten years goes by and everybody has their house.
One thing we related to, as people living in a community house, is that it is very important who is a part of this, who is in and who is out, and that is a consensus sort of decision. I had the idea that if we are going to buy land and homes together anywhere, we should all go on an international trip and travel together first. And then lots and lots of money to be wasted on legal people and documents, unless you bring in a legal person.
How many of us are actually interested in this kind of thing at some point in our life? · A lot of us are, no bullshit, interested in some version of this within fifteen years.
Right now my partner and I need to find a home. I live in the city, he lives upstate in a little cabin off his mom's property, and it is not working for us. We can afford a home but we do not want the suburban thing, we want land. I live in Utopia. I like living with my peeps. So if you seem like maybe you are my peep, yeah.
Describe the land you are looking for. It is fun to have specifics. · Lots of acreage. I really want a spring-fed pond if I can, but I will accept a stream at an elevation where I am not drinking the byproducts of my neighbour's sewage. Off-grid, and eighty percent food independent. Flexible, so maybe tiny homes that could be wheeled away, but also maybe a nine bedroom or five bedroom house to start with. The minimum viable product would be a five bedroom. And if you have a nature pie you could have some pies left open for rentals, so new faces come in and out, because it gets weird when it is always the same people. You could host a destination wedding once a year, charge a bunch of money for it, and pay for everything. But hopefully within biking distance to a village and driving distance to a hospital.
Are you committed to New York? · I am pretty committed to Woodstock, and if you wonder why that is the best spot for the Armageddon I will tell you later. Three things. A mountain range separates it both from Indian Point and West Point and from New York City, so if there is any type of nuclear explosion we are fifty miles outside. Then the elevation: you leave the swampy July New York and go up into the mountains where it is cool, and you just leave your windows open. You do not need an AC, you do not need the buzz of an AC unit or even a fan going at night. You can actually have it be quiet in Woodstock. And that mountain range separates you from any freeways, and it reduces the smog of New York City, because all of the city smog goes up.
On timing, the room sorted itself into six months, five years, and fifteen.
Rob Hurwich · What is coming to me is that I was enthralled to go around and listen to people actually having real conversations about this. I really appreciate everybody's wholeheartedness. And I have a question for folks. After doing this, does the idea of collective pooling, or coming together in this kind of way, feel more possible or less possible?
More.
Rob Hurwich · Do you feel more connected to the people around here? Is there one person in this room you might be interested in collaborating with to do something? Who is feeling worse?
I think it definitely highlighted that it is not as easy as just collect your money. There is clearly so much to consider. And it does take an initial founding investment of people who are really invested in taking the time to answer all those questions.
Rob Hurwich · I think we can do it. And maybe some of the idea of the exercise is just to say, this is really what it takes. If you really want to do this, it is possible, and you know what it is going to take for success, because we want to set ourselves up for success. It is probably a lot better to spend five hours hammering this stuff out rather than to invest money and time and effort over a year's time.
I just want to say the cards are awesome. It made it so much faster to get through and to see the scope and scale. So bravo on the cards.
I totally disagree. I found the cards to be really distracting, and they actually prevented us from getting to the practical points to a place where we can do something after this. And too much arguing over some of the nuances of the semantics.
That goes back to our earlier point. Are we using the cards and treating it as a game and doing what the cards are telling us? Or are we using our intuition?
Rob Hurwich · I think it is great feedback. The card game is a new kind of invention, so it can be refined.
There were so many questions here that I would not have thought to ask had I not had access to these cards. Like, oh, should I even think about that?
We decided exactly what the idea was that we wanted to do first, and then got into the nitty gritty of how to do it. Whereas if you focus on the nitty gritty, it is like, we are going to have some sort of collective thing, but we do not know what. So I thought it was useful, but it would have been helpful to just decide on the idea first.
Maybe an exploratory phase at the beginning, where you look through all of the cards and get ideas before even nailing down one idea. Not in the context of you have to look at these five. I was looking through them while my group was doing other things and I was getting ideas.
Something I have to say is how important actually having a crystallized shared purpose is. It was interesting, because I think we spun around for a while, because we all had different definitions of what collective power might be. Having that real clear idea of what we are actually trying to do together feels like a really important step.
Rob Hurwich · From all that feedback, it feels like no matter what we have all had a workout, building the kind of collective muscles to know, okay, this is how we can do this. And that is really valuable.
How long did it take you to make this?
Rob Hurwich · The last couple of days. There is a lot more refinement to do. But I had the taxonomy already, because of the research, and then it was a question of how you actually break this down, because it can be a little mystifying. I geeked out on it, made spreadsheets and databases to isolate how the pieces fit together, and from there I made the cards.
Can you email us the cards?
Rob Hurwich · Yes, absolutely. And Staples made a mistake and printed too many, so there are spare decks. If anybody really loves the card decks, take one.