Metacrisis Salon #16

Coops Against Collapse

Black Americans have been pooling money, land and labor since before the Civil War. Jessica Gordon Nembhard spent fifteen years proving that what the histories recorded as internal failure was usually sabotage from outside.

November 7, 2026 · Lightning Lofts, Brooklyn, NY

Missed the salon? Listen to it

Follow the podcast
Metacrisis Salon #16: Coops Against Collapse

1865

Maryland bars free Black caulkers from hiring themselves out. Baltimore buys a shipyard instead, and runs it for 18 years

1M+

members of the Colored Farmers National Alliance and Cooperative Union, a union, a populist party and a co-op developer at once

18 months

of weekly study in Gary, Indiana before a single co-op opened. By 1936 it was the largest Black-run grocery business in the country

$2.8M

projected 2026 revenue at Chi Fresh Kitchen, a Chicago meal prep co-op owned by formerly incarcerated Black women

Jessica Gordon Nembhard mid-talk, the room seated on every surface under the string lights.

In Coops against Collapse, Douglas Rushkoff took a short opening slot to put the evening on the ground: the addiction to scale is itself the problem, because the reflex that asks whether an idea is big enough kills the small ones that work, and preventing collapse and preparing for it turn out to be one job done at the size of a street. He used it to hand over to Jessica Gordon Nembhard, who he brought into the room, and who has the evidence. Black Americans have pooled money, land and labor since before the Civil War, through enslavement, Jim Crow and the Depression, and fifteen years in the archives taught her that the co-ops which died were mostly not badly run. They were lynched, denied credit, and refused freight. The room spent the second half on what it already has, and who it would trust to share it with.

Snapshots from the Evening

Part 1 · The Record

Jessica Gordon Nembhard

Professor of Community Justice and Social Economic Development, John Jay College, CUNY · author, Collective Courage

Jessica Gordon Nembhard standing at the microphone in a mask and head wrap, her title slide behind her: Act 1, Black American Cooperatives, Addressing and Overcoming Challenges, Dear Crisis, Brooklyn, November 7, 2026.

Every population in human history has practiced economic cooperation in some form, and she calls it the first economic system of all human beings. Human beings started in Africa, so the practice starts as an African one. The last 400 years of racial capitalism cut all of us off from it. When she first learned about cooperatives they were presented as a European invention, and the Black communities she spoke to did not see their own history or their own role in it. She set out to learn that history and then show it, and has pushed for the other ethnic and racial histories since.

  • Collective Courage: A History of African American Cooperative Economic Thought and Practice (Penn State University Press, 2014; tenth anniversary edition 2024). The event page calls it the first nationwide study of Black co-ops since W. E. B. Du Bois published his in 1907.
  • Her slide credits Esther West's 2020 study of Latinx co-ops, which scans the present rather than writing the history.

Enslaved people farmed plots next to their cabins in whatever off hours they had, so their families ate better than what the masters served. The Underground Railroad was a solidarity economic system: people pooling a wagon, food and knowledge of the route so that others could self emancipate. Then credit exchanges and equipment co-ops in rural areas, and from there the incorporated forms, agricultural, purchasing and food co-ops, credit unions, housing co-ops, worker co-ops. The early interest was survival. Once people used the model to survive they kept it, because it was humanizing and a better way to do business.

  • Economic cooperation includes informal pooling with no entity behind it. A co-op business, as she defines it, is incorporated, with rules about who counts as a member, what ownership looks like, and democratic governance.

Co-ops sit inside what she calls the long civil rights movement, which runs from the boats out of Africa and the chains through enslavement to the present. W. E. B. Du Bois, Ella Jo Baker, A. Philip Randolph and more were already immersed in cooperative economics. They promoted it, started it and taught it, because the legal, political and civic side was not enough for real liberation without economic justice and economic democracy.

  • Her list of Black organizations that promoted co-ops runs from the Colored Farmers National Alliance in the 1880s and the Negro Cooperative Guild in 1918, through the Young Negroes' Co-operative League that Ella Jo Baker ran in the 1930s, to Cooperation Jackson and the National Association of Black Cooperators today.

Reading about a Black co-op, she would find the writer explaining what the members did wrong and why it failed. The more she studied, the smaller those internal causes got. The decisive causes were external: white supremacist terrorism against the co-ops and the people in them, including lynching, banks refusing lines of credit and loans, shipping agencies refusing to move co-op goods. Funder meddling and the nonprofit industrial complex belong on the same list. White competitors destroyed these businesses deliberately because they did not want them to succeed.

  • Her barriers slide lists six: capitalization and access to non-extractive capital; orientation and training, which a co-op needs twice over because it is both a mutual association and a business; distrust and excessive competition; ideology; class politics and policy; racism and patriarchy.

The periods are the 1880s, the 1930s and 40s, the 1960s and 70s, and the 2020s, which she added in the introduction to the tenth anniversary edition. Survival need explains the 1880s, the 1930s and the 2020s. Active race consciousness and transition explains the 1880s, the 1960s and the 2020s. Needing economic independence in order to fight for political rights explains the 1880s, the 1930s and the 1960s. Black organizations focused on economic liberation and deliberate co-op development explain all four, one of her answers to why there were so many Black co-ops at all.

  • The 1880s were the backlash from Reconstruction and also a period when the labor, co-op, women's rights and racial justice movements worked together, often inside the same organizations. The 1960s and 70s were not bad economically; the pressure there was political.

Ordinary people came together to learn cooperative economics in order to address the problem in front of them, and that is how most of the co-ops she studied began. Her lessons learned slide starts there too: education, study groups and training, informal and formal, learning from each other. Then deliberate co-op organizing and organizational support. Then community involvement and solidarity, which she said she had not stressed enough: community members knowing what a co-op was doing and backing it mattered to its ability to pool resources at all. Then democratic participation and shared power, including the voices of the marginalized, Black women's leadership and youth participation, which she tied to whether a co-op lasts.

1865 was the first year Black people were free in Maryland, a slave state that stayed in the Union. Black stevedores and caulkers were the most skilled shipyard workers in Baltimore, and the state passed a law that they could not hire themselves out and had to work for white companies. Middle class Black Baltimoreans put up the startup money and the workers bought a shipyard, the Chesapeake Marine Railway and Dry Dock Company, so they could own the company that employed them. It ran from 1865 to 1883 and employed 100 to 200 Black and white workers a year.

  • It integrated the union over those years, so when the co-op went out of business every Black stevedore and caulker was already unionized and working at other shipyards.

The Colored Farmers National Alliance and Cooperative Union ran from 1886 to 1891 and held Black landowning farmers, sharecroppers and landless farm laborers in one organization, all fighting for Black community ownership, worker ownership and Black control over land. It set up cooperative stores that bought goods and supplies in bulk at reduced prices, shared equipment, secured loans so members could pay off mortgages or buy land, and marketed crops together. It argued as a union for higher wages. It also worked with the white Farmers' Alliance on co-op stores.

  • Probably over 1 million members, the largest Black organization of its time. It was often terrorized and operated underground, and members were hanged.

Paul Laurence Dunbar Housing Co-op opened in 1927 and Garrison House in 1929, followed by the 137th Street Housing Corporation and the United Harlem Tenants and Consumer Organization cooperative in the 1930s. Some of them still exist. Nine Black credit unions opened in the 1930s, attached to lodges, churches, alumni associations, the postal workers and the YMCA and YWCA, because white banks would not take Black money or gouged on the terms. We would call it subprime lending now; in those days it was just unfair lending.

  • The nine were the Tuscan Lodge, Abyssinian Baptist Church, Hampton Alumni, Postal Alliance, St. Martin's Episcopal Church, YMCA, YWCA, Mount Olivet Baptist Church and UMBA Federal Credit Unions.
  • Her Harlem grocery list runs from the Harlem Pioneer Cooperative Society in 1919, through Harlem's Own and the Harlem Consumers' Cooperative Council in the 1930s, to the Harlem River Consumers Cooperative in the 1960s and 70s. Most of them trace back to the Young Negroes' Co-operative League, run by Ella Jo Baker and co-founded with the Pittsburgh Courier columnist George Schuyler.

Teachers at the Black high school in Gary, Indiana came together during the Great Depression after the last bank in their neighborhood closed. No jobs, no bank, no grocery store, no gas station. They studied cooperatives, held weekly co-op education meetings for 18 months, then ran a night school course at Roosevelt High School in 1933 on how to start a co-op, and a second on how to manage one. By 1936 the course had the largest academic class enrollment. The buying club became the Consumers' Cooperative Trading Company, which added a credit union, a second grocery branch and a gas station.

  • The first co-op grocery store opened in 1935. By 1936 it was considered the largest grocery business operated by African Americans in the United States, with total sales of $160,000 and annual dividends of 2 percent.
  • Her Gary slide quotes Reddix: "The most important single factor in the co-op's success has been our education program."

The Women's Guild of the Consumers' Cooperative Trading Company reinvigorated the co-op movement in Gary in 1932 and grew the trading company's membership. In Washington DC, Nannie Helen Burroughs co-founded a set of production co-ops in 1936 that made brooms and clothing and canned food, and let them operate in the basement of the school for women and girls she had founded. Domestic work paid badly, sometimes went unpaid in those years, and left women exposed to sexual abuse by the men of the household. The co-ops gave them safe, dignified production work that paid real money.

  • The DC group began as the Northeast Self Help Co-op and became Cooperative Industries of DC. A New Deal grant added a co-op grocery store and an agricultural marketing co-op, and the group bought a farm, which made it an early multi-stakeholder co-op.

The Freedom Quilting Bee started in Alabama in 1967 when sharecropping women began selling their quilts for extra income, after a minister sold the first batch in the north and brought back the money. Within five years the co-op owned 23 acres of land, which mattered because as sharecroppers they farmed land they did not own. They built a sewing factory, which ended the work from home and created the need for the child care center, after school programs and summer reading program they then ran. They rented land to sharecroppers who had been evicted for registering to vote.

  • It became the largest employer and the main child care provider in its small town, and a founding member of the regional Federation of Southern Cooperatives / LAF.

Part 2 · What Exists Now

She is a co-op historian, a co-op advocate and a co-op educator, and the questions from the room about how to actually start one belong to technical assistance providers. She named the law clinic at CUNY School of Law and the community development law clinic at Fordham, co-op lawyers in the city who have spent about thirty years getting people from nothing to a housing co-op, the co-op community loan funds, and a nonprofit that helps tenants buy their own buildings and then teaches them to rehab their units affordably. She said she motivates people at the beginning of a conversation and somebody else should land it.

  • The loan funds she pointed to belong to the Seed Commons network, whose New York City member is The Working World. She described the financing as non-extractive, for worker ownership especially but also for housing co-ops.
  • New York State has good cooperative law, she said, and plenty of states do not.

Marion Barry promoted Washington's co-ops and wrote municipal policy for them, intending DC to be a demonstration city for cooperative development, and started a co-op development agency inside the mayor's office, run by Cornelius Gibbons. At least nine new food co-ops started in the DC area in the 1980s, along with about forty housing co-ops, several co-op housing federations and some worker co-ops. Chokwe Lumumba was elected mayor of Jackson, Mississippi in 2013 on a platform of making it a co-op city: co-op education once or twice a year, worker co-op development, and converting municipally owned services such as sanitation into co-ops. She said he died in his second year in office without control of the city council, and his whole vision never got in place. Cooperation Jackson, which he helped found, still operates.

  • Her slide dates the Jackson Rising conference to 2014, and the Jackson Kush Plan and Cooperation Jackson to 2016.

The Ocean Hill-Brownsville Tenants Association started a construction worker co-op in 1990 to give local construction workers decent jobs, then in 1992 started a worker-owned security company to guard its own housing complex, with training help from the Nation of Islam. About 20 percent of the 42 worker-owners had previously been incarcerated or were recovering from addiction. A tenants association forms worker co-ops to do the work its area needs done, so the place is more livable and the members hold the jobs.

Cooperative Home Care Associates began in the South Bronx in 1985, started by a social service agency to create decent jobs in a poor neighborhood, and has been the largest worker co-op in the United States for twenty years. Her figures: almost 2000 employees, 70 percent of them owners, and 75 percent of employee-owners who had previously depended on public assistance. Home care is contingent work with low pay, little training, no holidays and no union. CHCA is unionized, with health care, vacation time and retirement plans, and guarantees members full-time work wherever possible. The buy-in was $1,000, payable in installments out of wages, and dividends on membership equity reached 25 percent a year, so a member had the $1,000 back in four years and still held the stake.

  • The buy-in and the dividend are figures she gave from the stage and appear on no slide. She dated the 25 percent dividend to the 1990s and said it was paid in almost every year after 1990.

Cooperative Home Care Associates built coalitions with other nursing and home care companies, the for-profit ones among them, to get Medicare and Medicaid money directed to home care and the rates raised. New York City and New York State both set a base wage for all home care workers, which keeps the living wage it pays its member-owners competitive. Its own nonprofit training subsidiary runs the training, and the ladder goes from home care to assistant nurse to licensed practical nurse to registered nurse, with a route into managing the co-op for members who do not want to do home care forever. A second co-op specializes in disability home care.

  • Cooperative Home Care Associates' motto, as she quoted it: "high quality home care and high quality jobs."

Apex Taxi Cab Cooperative began in Milwaukee in January 1973 with thirty new cabs. Its advantage over the white cab companies was that its drivers would take passengers to any part of the city, and after about 18 months of relatively successful operation the insurance company decided those neighborhoods made the co-op too much of a risk and quadrupled the premium. They could not afford the insurance and went under. The Drivers Cooperative now runs Co-op Ride in New York City, launched in 2021, where members make 8 to 10 percent more on each trip than on Uber and Lyft and profits return as dividends. The aim is to keep the software in the hands of the drivers and the riders, so the money recirculates between them instead of going to outside companies.

  • The quadrupled premium is hers from the stage. Her slide says only that after 18 months they could not afford the high insurance premium.
  • The Drivers Cooperative's own line on her slide: "For better pay in the short term, and a just, green transition of the industry in the long term."

A union drive at the Chicago window factory became a fight when the company planned to move to Mexico and take the workers' retirement fund with it. Two factory occupations between 2009 and 2012 ended with them buying the business outright in 2012 and converting it to a worker co-op, New Era Windows, with help from their union, from The Working World and from the community. The building they had was too expensive, and a moving company quoted $40,000 to shift the equipment. They rented trucks, spent a week working out how to pack everything, and moved it themselves to a place at about half the rent. About five years in they changed unions, to one that could help them with the co-op model.

  • She heard the moving story first hand from one of the co-founders, on a bus at a worker co-op conference in Mexico City.

Toxic Soil Busters was a youth project of Worcester Roots in Massachusetts, founded by 15 and 16 year olds who worked out that runoff from old lead paint was washing into the yards where their younger siblings played. They joined an environmental justice group, learned about worker co-ops at a nonprofit that let them meet there, trained themselves in soil testing and lead abatement landscaping, and started the business. Customers did not know the problem existed, so they bought video equipment and built a studio in their office to explain lead poisoning and what could be done about it. They ran the business after school and on weekends, and still had to raise a hand to go to the bathroom in class.

  • She sits on the board of Green Worker Cooperatives, for 15 years one of the main trainers in the New York City worker co-op network, in composting, recycling, organic food and services such as doula work and photography done ecologically. She said it is struggling at the moment.

Food From the 'Hood started in Los Angeles in the 1990s, right after the rebellions, a high school garden whose produce went to a farmers market and to homeless people in the neighborhood. A business class at the school led the students to a value-added product, salad dressing, which they organized as a co-op and sold through Amazon in its earliest years. Knowing some of them would graduate, they voted to put half the profits into college scholarships, about $170,000 over the first ten years. They then taught middle schoolers to run the garden and the business so the incoming class could replace the graduating seniors.

  • The co-op ran about 15 to 20 years. Its high school added a college prep program once its students had both money and plans for college.

Food co-ops are one of the fastest growing parts of the movement. The Black food co-ops operating or organizing now: Gem City Market in Dayton, Detroit People's Food Co-op, Central Brooklyn Food Co-op, which had been organizing for a while and had not opened yet when she spoke, and Fertile Ground in North Carolina, which runs a Black-led caucus that goes to the food co-op meetings and puts Black co-op issues on the agenda. Gangstas to Growers in Atlanta trains justice-involved young people in horticulture and in starting worker co-ops, with ending recidivism as the point. Its first worker co-op is Sweet Sol, a hot sauce made from what the youth grow and harvest.

  • Her slide dates Gangstas to Growers from 2016.

Chi Fresh Kitchen started in Chicago in 2020, a meal prep worker co-op owned mostly by Black women who had been incarcerated and could not get hired anywhere else, trained and set up by a co-op development organization. Lockdown suited a business built to cook healthy food and deliver it to homebound people. Her figures: one of the largest Black-woman owned businesses in Chicago, $2.8 million in revenue projected for 2026, sustainable with no grant subsidy, 14 employees, and a fully rehabbed 6,125 square foot commercial kitchen they own. Two years ago they bought a building and started a housing co-op for members, then last year a second one.

  • A nonprofit called Volts holds the real estate, runs the back office for the co-ops, manages the housing and develops new ones. Her reason for the structure: people coming home from prison need wraparound support, and a good job in a worker co-op is not enough on its own.

What co-op development needs: internal education and study circles, public education and publicity, adequate resources and management training and financing, human energy and enthusiasm, solidarity and trust among members, local control alongside inter-cooperation, youth, and leadership roles for women. Her scorecard: capitalization is getting better, with more community development financial institutions that understand co-ops and more local co-op loan funds around the country, education is sort of okay but needs a lot more, and public knowledge that these options exist and work is far short of where it needs to be. Co-ops also recirculate resources, employ community members and donate back to the community, require a level of transparency because the decisions are democratic, and anchor economic activity in a community.

Questions that were asked in the room

You already took the first step by coming and taking part. The second depends on whether you want to be an ally or whether you have something in your own life that cooperative economics would help with. As an ally, donate to the co-op loan funds, support the movements working on enabling laws, and become a customer of the co-ops that already exist here in New York City. New York State has good co-op law. Other states do not. Right now we are trying to get a bill passed in California to let incarcerated workers start co-ops while they are in prison, and I have been consulting with some men at San Quentin who are trying to start a food co-op inside and who got a group to sponsor that law. If you want to do something in your own life, pull a group together, talk to people with a similar interest, study together, read a book or articles together, and bring in outside information or technical help when you need it. The model is flexible enough that I have not found an economic issue there is not a co-op model for.

Greedy people. This is not the model if you want to be a multimillionaire, or if you want to gouge people and take whatever you can get. I sat next to a banker at a business meeting once and told him about my work, and he said he would never share money with anybody, he makes millions. I told him he was right, he does not need to do this. Then I was in a hot tub at a birthday party with a middle manager who asked how co-ops work, and when I talked about exploitation and why the managers and the owners walk off with the money and do not pay anybody, he actually got interested. The other disqualifier is a commitment problem. If you are in it for a fast turnaround inside a year, it is not for you either. Co-ops tend to have better longevity because they take time and people's real commitment to make them work. I know a lot of stories about people who were far too busy to imagine helping start a co-op, who committed to it because it made sense, and whose lives got easier in the end.

Learn by doing, and start small. Some of the case studies literally started as a buying club, which is much smaller than a co-op grocery store. A few people pool money, somebody goes and buys with the money they have, and that starts you thinking differently: how much do you want to pool, what do you want to do with it, what responsibility do you want to take in the group. Starting small is often better, because people get to know each other and come to understand their own tendencies and what they need to purge or develop. Small victories are powerful if we claim them. We all do everyday acts of economic solidarity already and we do not claim them, do not always think about them, and usually do not name them. We borrow from each other and help each other out in all kinds of ways. So take it up a notch. Start doing it with a group, learn how to make decisions and how to reach one when nobody agrees, and get training. There are a lot of people now willing to teach us how to talk to each other, solve problems and work through conflict, if we are willing to learn it.

Succession planning. Some co-ops never orient the new people, so the new people do not have the same enthusiasm or the same history, they start taking the co-op for granted, and the level of commitment drops. Food From the 'Hood anticipated it: the students knew they were graduating, so they deliberately trained the people who would replace them. Some co-ops imploded because they never figured out co-op management, how to get people to disagree and still decide. A friend of mine was in a worker co-op that finally made a profit after five years and almost went under fighting over what to do with it. The lawyers I know now make you write that into your bylaws before the first profit exists, so it is not a fight anymore: say twenty percent back into the business and twenty percent out as dividends, built in from the start. The strongest co-ops I know, especially the worker co-ops, pay people to do the training and pay people to attend a board meeting, because they want to value people's time. Others rotate how much responsibility people have, or make decisions at committee level so everybody does not have to be at every meeting. Cooperative Home Care Associates has been going since 1985. As an economist, when I compare co-op lifespans to small businesses, co-ops do better. Mom and pop shops have lots of challenges and do not last that long either, and co-ops actually do better, but we do not always see it that way.

I never really talk about failure, because even if the business fails, the whole process of doing it was a win and everybody comes out better. W. E. B. Du Bois's writing introduced me to the Chesapeake Marine Railway and Dry Dock Company, and it did last eighteen years. It integrated the union, and everybody employed there went on to work at other shipyards when it disbanded. He called it a failure. I refuse to call it a failure. Doing what they did between 1865 and 1883, and integrating the union so that everybody still had good jobs and control over their work, is incredible. Sometimes they serve their purpose and they are done. What we should fight is the co-op that goes under or gets sabotaged before its purpose is finished. The definition of a co-op is a values based business that addresses a community need with a collective solution, so it is not going into business to maximize profit, which is why so many of the examples address a need. A need can also be anticipating one, or building the capacity for people to own and finance their own things. It does not have to be an immediate survival need, but it does have to be a social purpose.

Socialism is top down. It depends on government support, government policy, government legislating these things, and there is nothing wrong with that. For me the co-op model is stronger, because most co-ops are bottom up. From my studies, the things that bubble up from the grassroots, with grassroots people determining it, educating themselves to make it work, doing it, and then demanding that government provide the policy and the resources, make a much stronger model than people legislating it and saying, okay, everybody form a co-op. We develop policy and government support out of what we are already doing and what we say we need. On the other hand, it does not hurt to have democratic socialists in power, because they tend to be more interested in these kinds of projects, and if we start demanding things we at least have people willing to put resources into it. The two can go hand in hand. A socialist government saying let us do this is not going to be good enough on its own, or lasting enough.

Act II · Warm Data Lab

Four breakout rooms

Housing and land is the biggest thing on the wish list and the thing almost nobody shares. The room said up front that it was not the most action-oriented. One law that just passed, one it wants next, and the paperwork that has to exist before anyone moves in together.

COPA will let nonprofits match an outside offer on a distressed building before it sells

The Community Opportunity to Purchase Act came up as a route worth knowing about, and the room said twice that it needed to go and read the law. The City Council passed it on October 22, 2026, by 38 votes to 9. A qualified nonprofit gets notice that a covered building is for sale, time to put an offer together, and the right to match an outside offer. It takes effect a year after signing, so nothing can be bought under it yet.

TOPA, the law the room wants next, would give tenants the first chance to buy their building

The Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act would put that same right to match an offer in the hands of the people already living in the building, rather than a nonprofit buying on their behalf. It has not passed. The room named it as the thing to push for next.

Write the ownership agreement and a conflict plan before anyone moves in together

Bring lawyers in early and put it in writing while everyone still likes each other. Write a conflict resolution plan on the assumption that there will be conflict rather than hoping there will not, and an exit strategy for whoever leaves first. One person called the document a prenup.

Small private units around big shared rooms let someone leave with their assets

A private bathroom and kitchen in each unit, with the yoga room, the workspace and the living room shared. Someone who leaves takes their own unit with them instead of arguing over a share of the whole.

Unions built Co-op City and Penn South to stay affordable forever, and nobody builds that now

Both are union-built housing in New York, designed so the apartments stay affordable permanently, and they came up at the end as proof that this works at scale. Nobody builds it anymore, which is why most of the conversation stays stuck at the level of individual lots and single properties.

Douglas Rushkoff's drill, as a practical problem: what can be shared, what stops us, and how a sharing group gets started.

Rural neighbors leave the keys in the car; in the city borrowing comes with a stigma

Someone from southern Vermont said people up the mountain leave the keys in the car and tell neighbors to take it and bring it back. His town library lends drills, sewing machines and kitchen gear next to the books. In the city the obstacle is stigma: borrowing says you cannot afford to buy.

A drill you can do without for two days can be shared, an air fryer you use every other day cannot

A drill you can do without for two days works. An air fryer you use every other day does not, because once it is loaned out you may not see it for two weeks.

Most New Yorkers already live in a building with other units, so sharing can start there

Most people in New York already live in a co-op or condo building, or at least a building with other units in it, Jochen Weber said. Those neighbors are an easier starting group than a whole neighborhood, where the boundary has to be settled first.

Brooklyn's library lends drills and sewing machines, and the sewing machine wait runs past six months

One public institution serving all of Brooklyn is what produces a wait that long, and it is the argument for small groups.

A building tool share needs people to join by introduction and log what they borrow

The room wanted a deliberate way in, by introduction, plus a log of who took what and when, rather than membership arriving automatically with a lease. Shareable has templates for the rest.

Coordination and methods was the biggest thing stopping this room from pooling resources, so the group split the word into four layers. It called itself the least defined of the four breakout topics, said it had not solved society, and asked for more time.

Shared infrastructure has four layers: legal, social, technical and cultural

Legal infrastructure is the organizational structure. Social infrastructure is the design of how people work together. Technical infrastructure keeps track of what is shared. Cultural infrastructure is knowing there is precedent: without it, people assume the city or an NGO will handle a problem instead of asking what they could start with their neighbors.

Infrastructure includes WhatsApp, Couchsurfing and the design of an evening

Infra means below, so infrastructure is the structure underneath that shapes how people act. WhatsApp is infrastructure. Couchsurfing is infrastructure. So is the design of an evening, and the shape of a table that decides how people sit. The room noticed that the breakout rooms had produced a conversation the main room would not have.

Invitations slid under doors started a building group chat, because knocking felt intrusive

One person printed invitations with a QR code and slid them under neighbors' doors, because knocking felt like interrupting people's private lives. Two households still have not joined.

A group chat that helps tenants organize is a different tool from one the landlord also finds useful

An apartment-wide group chat that lets tenants organize against a landlord is a different tool from one the landlord would also find useful. The question of who benefits ran through the rest of the hour.

Not charging for a meal is easier than setting a price, forming an entity and paying taxes

Not counting the pennies someone owes you for a meal is easier than pricing it, and charging means a price, an entity and taxes. One person pushed back that a cooperative still needs a business model and revenue, which the room did not resolve.

Everyone in the house had already shared a meal that night. The conversation went to personal and professional experience rather than the mechanics of a food co-op.

Nearly every Brooklyn block has a community garden, and most of them are locked

One person's first introduction to cooperative anything was a community garden, one of the few third spaces open across backgrounds, cultures and generations. Nearly every block in Brooklyn has a plot. Most are locked, so finding out whether one is active means catching the gate open and asking whoever is sitting inside.

Shame is in the asking, so people in real need still refuse help

There is shame in asking, and accepting is harder still. People can be in real need and still refuse care. Put the question the other way around: how do we offer food so that dignity survives the transaction.

Mental and physical health are one subject: a bad day ends in ice cream rather than vegetables

A bad day ends in a pint of ice cream rather than vegetables, which makes mental health and physical health one subject rather than two. Two people who work in therapy and public health described care people cannot afford, and wanted a holistic version of it rather than a referral.

Metacrisis talk is inaccessible on its own, and food is the way in

Dear Crisis can be cerebral, sometimes hyper-intellectual, which also makes it inaccessible. Food is the one thing everyone in the room has in common, the access point and the foundation. One person said every public housing meeting they have thrown had pizza on the table, and that food is a critical piece of every movement being built.

Community Announcements from the room

Action Lab

The Economics of Trust

Rob Hurwich

Pooling resources, in practice. Tuesday at the same venue, capped at thirty.

Screenings

Rematriated Voices at Caravan of Dreams

MCK Michael Keefrider

Hidden Roots of Democracy on Nov 15, Matrilineal Men on Nov 22, with discussion after.

Nov 15 screening Nov 22 screening

Climate

Collective action through your Con Edison bill

NYC 2030 District

Cut demand at the hours that fire up the dirtiest plants, and sign up for solar. Fifteen minutes.

Mentors

111 mentors for 111 girls

Sara Surani

A documentary returning to girls it interviewed a decade ago, now 15 to 21. Gathering in March.

Mutual aid

A winter drive for housing insecurity

Leah Williams and Duckee

On-the-ground care through the winter, from two roommates who lived it. Looking for partner organizations.

Housing

A five bedroom upstate, split

Katherine Kennedy

Around Woodstock, shared evenly with co-owners who want more trees. One answer came from the floor.

Launch

Birdsong

Kaeshi Chai

A December 13 soft launch for a friend who knows New York's birds and plays music. Wants dancers, artists and costume people.

Practice

A monthly morning meditation

Brandon Levy

First one December 2, 8:30 to 10am. Meditation, qigong, then time to meet people.

Platform

Hyperlocal climate action

Sam Owen

Came down from Boston. Building a way to find neighbors who want to act on the same block.

Film

A revenue-share film platform

Zack

For films done with their festival run. Revenue shared platform-wide.

Care

Decolonized therapy offerings

Sara Surani

An art therapist hosting collective care sessions. Wants books and guidance back.

Peer support

A sexuality coaching practice

Lindsay Steadman

Starting one, and looking for both peers and people further along.

Artists wanted

Floats for a cargo bike fleet

Paid work building seasonal floats. Thanksgiving next, then the holidays. Sculptors especially.

Ocean

Ocean conservation education

Brandon Levy

The Next Wave, on AI and ocean conservation, November 17, 5 to 7pm. An open call to anyone already doing this work.

Links and Resources

Listen

The speaker

The research

Named in the room

From earlier salons

☞ All salon recaps☞ Were you in the room? Give us feedback