Metacrisis Salon #16 · Cleaned Transcript
November 7, 2026 · Lightning Lofts, Brooklyn, NY
Recorded by Mike the pigeon, our tiny mic mascot. This is a cleaned and condensed transcript: filler trimmed, crosstalk smoothed, the shape of the night kept intact. It is not verbatim. Hosts and speakers are named; everyone else in the room is not. Names, dates and figures are checked against the speaker's own slides, which win wherever the recording and the deck disagree.
Download as .txtBen · Thank you all so much for coming. A couple of people will undoubtedly arrive late, so if we can grab seats as far forward as possible, that would be great. Let me give you a quick welcome to the space. This is called Lightning Lofts, a 17-person community house, and a bunch of us who live here are in the room, so put your hands up. This is one of our living rooms, and we are really happy to welcome you into our home. It is sort of perfect for this theme on collectives.
Quick housekeeping, because I want everyone to get comfortable. Food, drinks and cleanup: this is all volunteer run. We will create little opportunities for you to pass your dirty dishes forward, so please do that rather than leaving them lying around, because that is how things get spilled. If you opened one of those sparkling waters, please drink it. Do not take one sip and leave it somewhere. Take care of the space as if it was your own. We have three bathrooms, one directly behind here and two through the kitchen, and we will make openings for people to get up, so nobody is stuck in a corner.
We have a few agreements we like to put into the space, just for today. If you have objections or additions, this is a good place for that, but we find it helpful to ground in a little shared agreement for this container of our time together.
Welcome the stranger. There are a lot of new faces here, and probably a lot of people who have been here before. Who is new? All right. Take a look around, the new people are mostly on the left side of the room, so make sure they feel welcome. Who has been to at least one other event? That is everyone else. It is phenomenal that so many people keep coming back, and that it has grown into a really lovely community.
Share the space, and land the plane. One person speaks at a time and there are a lot of people in the room. Land the plane is a phrase Hope brought from the work she has done, so if someone gently invites you to sunset your question or comment, please do not be offended by it. We are just making sure everyone gets a chance to speak.
Hold the tension, and do not rush to resolve it. Part of why we host these salons is that this is an uncomfortable time to be alive when you look around the world. There is a lot going on and there are different opinions in the room. We are not necessarily here to agree on anything, and we think this is a good place to sit in the discomfort of not really knowing. If something feels uncomfortable, feel free to name it. We do not have the answers, and we are not pretending to have the answers.
Explore kinship over transactions. I know I force everyone to fill in a LinkedIn field when you buy a ticket, but this is really not about what job you do. It is mostly about who you are, what you care about and how you show up in the world.
Real feedback is always welcome. This is a co-created space and an ever evolving experiment. Everything that is here, from the backjacks to the second air conditioner to having desserts at all, is a byproduct of feedback we received. So if you have comments, please let us know.
And thank the chefs. Thank the chefs, physically and metaphorically. This is an entirely volunteer held event. Someone had to set up the rooms. Someone is going to do the cleanup. A bunch of people came and cooked the food today. If you contributed to making tonight possible, lift your hands up. What makes this fun is that it is a co-created project.
Ben · Joseph, who is the chef of this food, wanted a moment to tell you what he prepared for us and why he is doing it, since he is a professional chef. Why is he here hanging out with us from two in the afternoon?
Joseph · I will keep this really brief and land the plane. I was a long time fan of Ben's work before I knew him, and for a while I only knew him as the artist. After I met him in March, I found out he was hosting these events, and it struck me as such a big gift for the community, so I was really drawn to that. I have not been able to get to many of the metacrisis ones, just scheduling conflicts.
So I asked myself what I could do to contribute. I think everyone has something, maybe a superpower, maybe a passion, that you can contribute and give back to other people. For me, I can cook for large amounts of people without becoming the angry chef. It is a pretty calm and loving environment in the kitchen.
A lot of my work now is around food security, sustainability and global food systems, and how our actions affect the world around us. Where food comes from and how we eat it is such a big part of our own health, the health of the environment, and the health of the planet. So I come to this with a lot of joy, and as you saw, a handful of people here had a big part in cooking and sharing the food today.
What I would love for you to take away, and to consider, is this: what is the awesome thing you have that you could give back to others? You might not even know or appreciate how much it means just to listen, or to offer someone food, or to invite someone over for dinner. We have a couple of desserts coming. The chia pudding with fruit and dark chocolate is over there. Please enjoy.
Ben · For the new folks in the room, what is Dear Crisis? It was essentially me trying to find friends who felt like something was not quite right in the world and wanted to come together around that. What started off as a series of little conversations with friends turned into what you see today. We host action labs, we were hosting creatathons for a while, and now we have these metacrisis salons.
We are constantly trying to explore what it means to build community, and what it means to transform discomfort into an opportunity to gather. To take something where we feel alienated and alone, and compost that feeling, transmute it into something that brings us closer together.
We have also built an app. Over the last couple of months we have been collecting information from people saying which events they have come to and what they care about, and it gives a home to all of the recordings and the summaries of what has happened. It is a little ecosystem for people to hopefully find each other. It is a bit of an experiment, so this is something I would also love feedback on.
During the Q&A we will put a QR code up so you can log in. What you will see is a live slide of the app in this moment: five people you could meet who you probably have not been to an event with yet, the tab where you ask your questions, the poll results, where you get to find who else in the room answered the way you did, and the people, which is ultimately why you are here. Community notes are in there too.
When I think of the salons we have built, the content is the excuse to bring people together. What we are really trying to build is relational connection with others who see the world the same way, who want to do something, who feel moved to try to do something about it. Hopefully this can be one piece of that puzzle.
Ben · I wanted to give everyone a sense of who is in the room. Everyone is always annoyed that there is a poll, because it means answering questions before you can buy a ticket, but the answers are interesting. One of the questions we asked was: what is the number one thing keeping you from pooling resources with others? Coordination and methods, the technical detail of how you actually do it, came first at 29 percent. Money, time and stability, 21 percent. Finding the right people, 16 percent. Trust and conflict, 13 percent. Not used to sharing, 13 percent. Other, 8 percent.
I am assuming most people here are already interested in pooling resources, otherwise you would not be in the room. So at least we can work on the finding the right people piece tonight, or start chipping away at it. And with Jessica here, and everything she is going to share, we might find the other pieces together.
Before we go into presentation mode, one of the big incentives here is for people to get to know one another, so I want to give you five minutes. Turn to a person you do not know, or do not know well, and tell them why you are here. Introduce yourself through a challenge that occurred in your life, a choice you made, and an outcome that emerged from it. A challenge, a choice, an outcome.
Before you do that, for the folks standing, is there anywhere else we can seat you. There is one chair there, and you can lean against the sofa here and next to here. Okay. Looks like we are good. Take five minutes.
Quickly, why I phrased the question that way. I read it in a book. It helps reset our minds to remind them that we have agency, that there is a moment in time where we are faced with a challenge, we make a choice, and something changes as a result. That is why I thought it would be a fun way of framing a little introduction.
Editor's note: from the stage Ben read three of these figures as 30 percent, 20 percent and 50 percent. The numbers above are the ones on the slide.
Ben · Just so you have a sense of what happens tonight. We have a few moments. We open. Wow. That is not on the plan. Explosions. Then a moment of community coherence, which Douglas is going to lead. Normally that is the slot where I try to weave in what the metacrisis is, why we are here, how we got here. Then Jessica comes and speaks to us for part one, and we have a discussion, which doubles as a break, so you get to turn to someone next to you and share how you are feeling based on what has come up so far. We share back into the room, then part two, then Q&A, then community announcements.
It is a fairly packed evening, but we try to break it up so nobody is sitting for too long. At that point about half the room usually leaves, because it is a Saturday night and you are all stacking parties, and I do not know how you do it. Then we come back into the room. Anyone who needs to go steps out, and the rest of us do a warm data lab. We live in a seventeen person community house, so we have a number of other rooms, and we set up breakout rooms for people who want to work on one of these topics and dive in. Then we share back into the room, close the space, and you get to do whatever you want. Does that sound good?
And with that being said, Douglas has been part of the community for, what, almost a year now. He has been working on these issues for far longer than I have, and he is the reason Jessica is here, because he introduced her to me. I thought it would be a wonderful opportunity to show how this community is actually built by people stepping up, doing their thing, finding resonance with each other, and coming together. Douglas, would you like to give us a little talk?
Douglas · I have never actually been a fan of the word metacrisis. When we think about all the various kinds of crises that are out there, it does not only feel overwhelming, it can focus us more on the figure than on the ground. We focus on the television image of climate change, fascism, Trump, electromagnetic pulse, ocean warming, mass migration, nationalism. Those are big ideas, and big ideas beg for big interventions. And as a fellow victim of the industrial age, I am a person who is also prone to thinking about solutions in terms of scale. You come up with a nice idea that helps some people, and then someone comes along and says, well, yes, but does it scale? In other words, if it does not scale then it is not worth talking about, because it is not going to address the metacrisis. What I have come to believe is that this addiction to scale is itself the problem.
So I have stopped worrying so much about whether my job is to prevent collapse or to prepare for collapse, and I have come to believe those are kind of the same thing. And whenever I start worrying about whether the things I am coming up with are big enough, because I write books and they go to a lot of people and they are supposed to be big, I go the other way and try to get it as small as I can, small enough that I can feel the ripples of my own impact. How small an action can I take?
I had an experience I have told at conferences sometimes, with mixed results. My daughter had just graduated high school and we got the framed portrait they give you, and I needed to put it up over the fireplace. I live in a house with plaster walls, and you cannot just put a nail in plaster. I needed a drill, I needed to set an anchor, I needed to do the whole thing. And I did not have a drill.
The first thing that occurs to me, as it occurs to anyone, is that I will go to Home Depot and get the minimum viable product, a rechargeable drill, so I can drill this one hole. I will buy that drill, use it once, stick it in the garage and probably never use it again. Or if I do take it out in two years it will not hold a charge, and I will throw it away. So I will have sent kids into mines in the Congo to get the rare earth metals to make the drill. There is the whole carbon footprint of the thing. All my money goes to Home Depot. And when I am done with it I throw it out, and it ends up in a toxic waste pile in Brazil, where some other kid is rummaging through that stuff to find the recyclable part and sell it to Apple, so Apple can say it is using green engineering.
And I am doing all of that just to avoid going down the street, knocking on a door and saying, Bob, can I borrow your drill? Why am I so afraid to ask Bob if I can borrow his drill? He is out there all the time doing things I do not even understand outside his garage. He has the tools. I am afraid because Bob is not going to lend me a drill. He is going to say, Doug, you do not know how to drill a fucking hole. You do not know how to put in an anchor. You are a nerd from CNN. You do not know what you are doing.
Douglas · He is going to come over with his own drill, plug it into the wall, find the stud, drill the hole, set the anchor and put the picture up. And then the next weekend, when I am having the barbecue for my daughter's graduation party, he is going to smell the barbecue coming over to his house and think, what the fuck, I put up the picture of Doug's daughter and he does not even invite me. So I am going to invite Bob. And then Bob's wife. And then Bob's mother, who sees the piano and says, oh, Christmas, we should come over. And then other people on the block see it, and why is he friends with Bob all of a sudden, I thought he liked us better than Bob and that family, they are not even Jewish. So now I have to invite the whole block over, or everyone is going to be pissed off. And instead of my private barbecue I have got the whole street over celebrating my daughter's graduation.
And that is the nightmare. Because now I have borrowed this thing. What do I owe him? Am I going to have to tutor his daughter in algebra? And then someone at the party comes over and says, how did all this happen? Well, I borrowed Bob's drill.
And then you think, we all have stuff we do not really use. Why does every family on this block have a lawnmower? Between everyone on this block we could probably have one or two lawnmowers and just share those, rather than everyone having to own and maintain a lawnmower of their own.
I told this story at the wrong conference once and a guy got up and said, this sounds great, with you all sharing lawnmowers and drills or whatever, but what about the lawnmower company? And I said, fuck the lawnmower company. We are not depending on the lawnmower company. Then one guy says, well, what about the old lady who lives on your block, who depends on the dividends from her stock in the lawnmower company to pay for her retirement? And what we are doing by meeting everyone on the block is building a world where that old woman is not dependent on her dividends from an S&P 500 company.
And when I share this story at nice-left-white-people conferences, someone invariably gets up and says, yes, those solutions are great, but what about poor, Black, urban people? How are they going to be able to get on board with this? What I want them to know, and what Jessica's work is about, is that they beat you to it by like three fucking centuries. The cooperative dynamics that nice circular donut economics geniuses like me talk about were invented by enslaved people still in chains on the boats, before they even got here.
We watched Watchmen, and the first episode opens on this nice Black district, and people said, wow, Black people were rich back then, were they? There are these wealthy people, and then all these whites come in and do this horrible, murderous riot. That is the Greenwood district of Tulsa, Oklahoma, and the interesting thing about it is that it was not just Black people getting rich. This was a district that was intentionally disenfranchised. It was cut off from the greater economy. If you could not have a Walmart to work at, or whatever the equivalent was back then, you needed to develop circular economic systems so the place could survive. So people learned how to do circular economics, how to do cooperative enterprise, how to take care of each other.
And the thing was, the whites who were living around there could not understand it. Wait a minute, these people are cut off from the economy and they are doing better than we are? Yes, because the big economy, the big scale economy, is extractive. It takes value out of your community. So the people who were cut off from the big economy ended up doing better than the people around them, and that is why those people went in, because they could not tolerate it. They needed the disenfranchised Black people to be poorer than them, not wealthier than them.
So when people say that we need to somehow bring our great brilliant donut, white, lefty economic principles to inner city Black people, or that it will be a challenge to bring them, I say no, let us flip that. We actually need to learn what it is they did, all of these centuries, and what they are actually still doing. This book came to my rescue in that pursuit, so I am happy to bring one of my true heroes to this event, Jessica Gordon Nembhard. You do not see many facts, or much history, in a lot of our prognostication. You see a lot of future-casting, but not a lot of retrieval of things that have actually worked, and of the stories of the genuine courage it takes to stand up in a moment like this one. So thanks for listening to me. Here is my friend Jessica.
Jessica · Good evening, everybody. I am going to stand here for a little bit, because a long time ago someone told me that women, and small women, need to stand up to be seen and heard. So let me start by standing.
I also want to explain the mask. I am not actually sick. My dad is 105, and I try not to bring germs to him, so I wear my mask as much as I can.
Thank you all for coming. I almost feel like I do not need to say that much, because so much has been said already, but I know you are here for a story, so we will have some stories. I want to talk about the way Black Americans throughout our history here in the United States have used mutual aid, collective economics and solidarity economics in the face of what normally would be insurmountable odds.
Let me start by thanking you for having me, and by acknowledging the indigenous land we are on. This is Lenape land. Honor the original stewards of the land, and honor the treaties. Honor our ancestors. Acknowledge the African origins of all humanity, and all the African descendants forcibly brought to this stolen land and enslaved, as well as those who continue to labor without just compensation. Honor Mother Earth and the efforts to keep this planet livable. And recognize the histories of resistance and restoration: resist and build. That is what I hope you hear from me tonight, how we resist inhumanity and resist exploitation, and build humanity, cooperation and collective well being.
The other thing to say is that even though I talk about Black American economic cooperation, solidarity and mutual aid, I honestly believe it is a universal human phenomenon, and I believe it is the first economic system of all human beings. Human beings started in Africa, so it would then be an African practice, but every population in human history, in every epoch and era, has practiced it in some way or another. Especially over the last 400 years of racial capitalism, we have all been alienated from it.
I took it upon myself to look at what was happening in Black America once I got excited about cooperatives. I wanted to understand how Black Americans used the model, because when I first learned about it, it was supposed to have come from Europe. And when I talked to Black communities about it, they did not see their own history or their own role in it. So I wanted to learn about it, and then show it. I guess I did not need the picture of the book up there, because it is right here.
I have also been encouraging other people to do other ethnic and racial histories of cooperatives. One of my colleagues, Esther West, started something on Latinx co-ops. She did not do the history so much as a scan of what was happening in 2020. I put it up there to show that there is more research needed, and more information we could all be looking at.
Jessica · The roots of economic cooperation start with mutual aid. I say economic cooperation rather than co-op businesses in general, because sometimes it is just solidarity economics, just doing things together, pooling resources informally. But I was also specifically studying when African Americans come together, pool our resources and start actual co-op businesses. A co-op business means an incorporated enterprise that follows rules about what being a member is, what your ownership looks like, and democratic governance. Joint ownership plus democratic governance.
I did not add a slide on what a co-op is. I was hoping you all knew. You can ask me later, because the other problem is that I have way too much to say for 20 minutes. If there is something you need to know, we have a Q&A, and you can ask me, or ask each other, because people here will know.
Black co-ops started with food security. Even enslaved people had kitchen gardens, making sure their families had better nutrition than what the enslavers were serving. They farmed together on little plots next to their cabins, in whatever off hours they had, which was what, about 12 hours a week.
And if you understand the Underground Railroad, that is a solidarity economic system. What do we mean by that? People coming together to help others self emancipate, to move from slavery to freedom: pooling their resources, having a wagon, food, knowledge about the direction and how to get out of the place. A whole bunch of people working together to make sure the people who wanted to self emancipate could.
Then actual cooperative farming, credit unions, credit exchanges, equipment co-ops, equipment exchanges, because we could share equipment. That kind of thing was happening in rural areas. And then on through to the more formal: food co-ops, purchasing co-ops, credit unions, housing co-ops, worker co-ops.
Early on, a lot of the interest was just to survive. But I also learned, studying the co-ops that came out of that, that once people started using the model to survive they also realized it was a humanizing model and a better way to do business. So they continued to use it, sometimes long after the crisis that started the cooperation had passed.
Here is a quick sketch of the ways co-ops can address most of the economic problems I saw. I started this as a list of urban problems, and then I talked to some Black rural people and they said it is almost the same list in rural areas too.
I also found that co-ops were really part of what I call the long civil rights movement. From when we were on the boats, forcibly brought here from Africa in chains, to when we were enslaved on US soil, to the present, we have always looked at the ways we could help each other economically, not only at our political and civil rights. So it was really interesting to me when I started this research to find that a lot of the same civil rights heroes and leaders were also part of a co-op movement, or promoting co-op development, even though we do not know them for that. I mean people like W. E. B. Du Bois, Ella Jo Baker, A. Philip Randolph. When you get into Black co-op history it turns out all of them, and more, were immersed in cooperative economics, promoting it, starting it, teaching it, because they realized that the legal, political and civic aspects were not enough for real liberation if we did not have economic justice and economic democracy.
Jessica · The barriers are the same barriers as for any kind of economic thing. Whether you have enough capitalization, and access to non-extractive capital. Whether you have enough orientation and training, which matters especially for co-ops, because they are mutual associations as well as economic businesses. You have to understand the business side and how to relate to other people. They are run democratically, so you have to understand how to make decisions with other people, how to get along with other people. There are a lot of different levels of training.
You need to figure out how to get rid of the distrust and the excessive competition, and how to get rid of the ideology that the individual does it better, that individual greed is supposed to be the driver when really collective need and collective responsibility is the driver. You have to get past the class politics, and the racism, and the patriarchy. All of those things have gotten in the way, and none of them stopped the activities I am about to tell you about.
I also found a history of deliberate sabotage. Not just the ordinary difficulty of working with other people. In the case of Black Americans there was white supremacist terrorism against the co-op movement, against the cooperatives themselves and against the people in the co-ops, including lynching. And down from that level: banks refusing to give lines of credit or loans to a co-op, shipping agencies refusing to transport the co-op's goods. All levels of what I call sabotage.
Often I would read about a Black co-op and the writer would talk about what the co-op did wrong and why it failed. Then the more I studied it, the more I found that the things we thought internally made the co-op fail were minor. The major things were the external sabotage that the white supremacist world was leveling against the co-ops. So I was able to tell the story with different lessons learned. Instead of the lesson being what we as a Black community did not do right, or what training we did not have, a lot of the story was that we were preyed upon, and our co-ops were destroyed deliberately, because white competitors did not want us to succeed.
And through all of that, the resilience, which is what I want to talk about. The failures were an opportunity to learn. They made us stronger, we learned and kept moving, and when one thing did not work we tried other things. We had grand plans and we backed them up with theory. We had a lot of applied theory, because we had a lot of Black leaders who were willing to both learn and teach about how to do this. And most of the co-ops I learned about actually started as study groups, just ordinary people coming together to learn about cooperative economics together in order to address a problem.
That is what the rest of this presentation is about. I am going to give you a community problem, and then an example of a co-op that got set up to fix it.
I am not sure my little eyes can read all of this from here, but here is what the co-ops were able to do. Pool resources. Provide better quality goods and services, and access to them. Save costs, increase income, combat racial discrimination, increase economic stability and self sufficiency. Keep resources circulating inside a community instead of all that extraction. And develop agency and action, which is what we all did in our little introductions tonight, seeing how we are agentic people. You learn a lot about human agency when you study economics, even though that is not what economists are supposed to study. You learn that human beings always try to humanize things, even under the worst conditions.
Jessica · There are three periods in the book that were most prolific for Black co-ops, and I have added the 2020s, because I have noticed that is a prolific time too. I talk about it a little in the introduction to the 10th anniversary edition, which is the one on sale here. So: the 1880s, the 1930s and 40s, the 1960s and 70s, and the 2020s.
The 1880s are the backlash from Reconstruction, and also a very progressive period, when the progressive parties, the labor movement, the co-op movement, the women's rights movement and the racial justice movement were all actually working together. The organizations that were really doing things in that period were collective, and they spanned all of those movements at once. I have one example for you from that period, the Colored Farmers National Alliance and Cooperative Union, which was a labor union, a populist party and a co-op development organization, owned and run by Black farmers and landowners as well as sharecroppers and landless farm laborers. A really unlikely group of people, all in the same organization, fighting for the same thing: Black community ownership, worker ownership, Black control over land, and the reassertion of Black rights. The 1880s were also when the Ku Klux Klan starts up and segregation starts. It was a real backlash period.
The 1930s: the Depression. There was definitely economic need there, and also a lot of Black organizations deliberately doing co-op development and connecting economic rights to their other activities. The 1960s and 70s were not so bad economically, but it was a time of a lot of racial justice and civil rights activity, and you need some economic independence in order to fight for political rights. And then the 2020s is a combination of all of those periods. We have strong Black organizations doing co-op development, we have economic need, and we have a combining of movements again.
I will skip this one, but it is a list of the predominant Black organizations through our history that were doing co-op development or promoting co-ops. I argue that one of the reasons that explains why there were so many Black co-ops is that there were strong Black organizations promoting co-op development and supporting it, even at local levels.
Jessica · First problem, 1865. Hopefully you all know that is the end of the Civil War. We are in Baltimore, in Maryland, a slave state that stayed in the Union, so 1865 is the first time Black people are free in Maryland. The Black stevedores and caulkers there are known to be the most skilled shipyard workers. And the state of Maryland passes a law saying that Black stevedores and caulkers cannot hire themselves out. They have to work for white companies.
So what do the Black folks in Baltimore do? They start the Chesapeake Marine Railway and Dry Dock Company. A middle class of Black Baltimoreans put in the money for the startup, to create a worker co-op of Black stevedores and caulkers, so they could own their own company and not have to work for white folks. Between 1865 and 1883 they employed 100 to 200 Black and white workers a year. They also integrated the union over those years, so by the time the co-op went out of business all the Black stevedores and caulkers were already unionized and able to work in other places. There is a lot more I could say, and you can ask me for more detail if you want, but I am going to go quickly through these, the problem and then the solution.
Black farmers under Jim Crow. What do they do? The Colored Farmers National Alliance and Cooperative Union, 1886 to 1891. They came together as a political party, as a union, and as a co-op development agency, to start worker construction co-ops, worker farm co-ops and worker cotton mills, and to argue as a union for higher wages for farm workers and for land ownership for sharecroppers. Probably over a million members, which made it the largest Black organization of its time. It is fascinating to think that it was a labor union and a co-op developer and a mutual aid society and a populist political party, all at once. That is an example of combining all of those movements into one, and of how powerful that can be.
They established cooperative stores to buy goods and supplies in bulk at reduced prices. They shared equipment. They started credit exchanges so Black farmers could get decent loans, pay off their mortgages, buy land and stop being sharecroppers. They did cooperative marketing, and they connected with the white Farmers' Alliance on co-op stores. They were heavily terrorized by white supremacist terrorists and often operated underground. Many of their members were lynched. A lot of their buildings were burned.
Harlem in the 1920s and 30s, and the need for affordable housing. Here I am just listing a bunch of Black housing cooperatives, some of which still exist to this day. The Paul Laurence Dunbar co-op of 1927. Garrison House of 1929. The Dunbar went back and forth: it was a co-op first, then somebody bought it and it was a regular apartment building, and I think it converted back to a co-op in the 1950s. There were a bunch of different housing co-ops in the 20s and 30s, and nine Black credit unions in the 1930s. So again, the question is how you get access to loans and to financial services, especially when white banks will not even let you put your money in, or are gouging you. Now we would call it subprime lending. In those days it was just unfair lending.
The need for a Black grocery store. There are lots of examples, but I picked Gary, Indiana, also during the Great Depression. That one is an interesting story, because it started with some teachers at the Black high school coming together after the last bank in their neighborhood closed. They said, what are we going to do? We do not have jobs, we do not have a bank, we do not have a grocery store. So they started studying cooperatives: 18 months of weekly co-op education meetings. Then they offered a night school adult education course on how to start a cooperative, and a second course on how to manage one. Eventually they started a buying club, and that became the Consumers' Cooperative Trading Company: a grocery co-op, a credit union, a second branch of the grocery store, and a gas station. And their Women's Guild was also very important, which is another theme for another day, how important Black women's leadership is in all of this.
And since we are New Yorkers, I gave you the Harlem grocery stores too, mostly because of the Young Negroes' Co-operative League, a national co-op organization in the 1930s that was run by Ella Jo Baker and co-founded with a man named George Schuyler, who was a Pittsburgh Courier columnist and lived in Harlem.
Better working conditions for women. Lots of examples, but this one is also in the 1930s, in Washington DC. It was eventually called Cooperative Industries of DC, and it started out as the Northeast Self Help Co-ops. A set of industrial co-ops, meaning production co-ops: canning, sewing, that kind of thing, for women. Started by Nannie Helen Burroughs, another civil rights and women's rights figure who is not well known for the co-op work. She helped start them and let them operate in the basement of the school for women and girls that she had created in Washington. She wanted to make sure that domestic workers, women who normally had domestic work, could actually be producers, could have real production work in worker co-ops that they owned themselves, so they would not have to do domestic work. Especially in the 1930s, domestic work did not pay very well. Sometimes they did not get paid at all, because the times were so bad. And they were often sexually abused in the households, by the householder or his sons. She wanted them to have much more safe, dignified work that gave them real money, and she was able to create a whole set of interlocking industrial work co-ops in 1930s Washington.
Sharecropping is debt peonage. It is a lose lose proposition for the sharecropper. So what about women who do quilting? The Freedom Quilting Bee, in Alabama, from the 1960s. These women were encouraged by their minister to sell their quilts. He sold the first batch in the north and brought them back the money. They started a co-op, and within five years they were able to buy 23 acres of land. That is important, because remember, these were sharecropping women. They did not own the land they were farming with their families, and now they had a co-op that owned property. They built the sewing plant, so they stopped working from home. And since they were not working from home anymore they needed childcare, so they started childcare programs on their land, after school programs, summer reading programs. They also rented out some of their land to sharecroppers who had been evicted for registering to vote.
Because they were in a co-op, because they had pooled their resources and were making money from their art, they were able to be politically active, able to get out of sharecropping, able to buy land, able to help their community. For a while they were the largest employer in their small town, as well as the major childcare provider in town.
This is my last slide for this section. Hopefully I did not go too fast. Lessons learned. Education and study groups are very important: learning from each other, informal study, formal study, specific training. Organizational supports, and the importance of having the deliberate organizations that are doing this kind of work and making sure people learn what they need to learn to do it. Solidarity and community support. I did not talk about that as much, but in all of those cases, having community members know what they were doing and be supportive of their work also mattered. Pooling resources, and access to non-extractive resources. Democratic participation and the sharing of power, which develops social capital and leadership, so you are also developing capacity in people, not just economic stability. Black women's leadership was very important. And bringing youth along. I did not really talk about youth co-ops. I think I have one example for the recent period, in the next session. But it turns out that involving youth early on also matters to sustainability.
I think that is it. Thank you.
Ben · In the polls we put up before tonight, one of the things we wanted a sense of was who in here is already practicing some form of cooperative ownership, and what it is we share. Housing, land and property came first at 38 percent. Tools and equipment at 18 percent, utilities and infrastructure also at 18 percent. Childcare and healthcare at 16 percent, food at 13 percent, transportation at 10 percent. Sorry, this is the wish list. This is the set of things people wish was community owned.
One hope in asking that question is that these could be the prompts for a future conversation. Are there people in this room who want to start thinking about how we might make this possible? Hearing how other people did it in the past, in much harder conditions, is what makes it feel possible now.
The other question was what resources you currently share with others outside your household. Knowledge, skills and network at 39 percent. Time, labor and care at 34 percent. Things and tools at 31 percent. Space, land and gardens at 25 percent. Food and meals at 23 percent. Money at 21 percent. So the number one thing we actually share is knowledge and network, with time and labor second, things and tools after that. Very little of what we were hoping for on the first list shows up on this one. The gap between the two lists is the interesting part.
You have been sitting for about an hour, so we want to give everyone a chance to turn to the person next to you and keep talking, or stand up, stretch, get some food. Right before that, let us practice a little collective coordination. If you have a dirty dish, pass it forward. If you want to use it again for more food, keep it. It stops people from tripping over each other's stuff, and we have done this many times, it works pretty well.
And if you need the bathroom, now is a really good time to get up. There are only three of them and it takes a little while.
Then ten minutes with someone, ideally someone you have not talked to yet. What resources would you want to pool, and why? What is keeping you from doing it? Think about it from the perspective of the conversation we just had. Has your answer shifted? What feels more possible, and what feels less? We will ring a bell, and if any nuggets come through, we will share them back with the room.
Ben · I know some of you took a break, and I also saw how many conversations were happening around the room. This is always a fun part. What came up when you talked to the person next to you?
From the room · One of the challenges we talked about was housing. Even in New York City, with all the agencies you need approval from, and the amount of capital it takes, nobody who is working class has that kind of money to buy the land or the building.
Ben · Plant that seed in your brain, and bring it back as a question for Jessica.
From the room · In my group we were talking about how hard it is to know which cooperative communities already exist, other than the Park Slope Food Coop. How do we get more visibility on what is already around, because that is part of what keeps people out.
From the room · Something we talked about briefly: a lot of the examples were people of a similar class or a similar racial background. In co-ops now, where you have different races, different classes, different systems of hierarchy, how do we have difficult conversations and give feedback in a way that is constructive, so these spaces stay sustainable?
From the room · I said clothes. I have so much of it in my room, and that would be nice to share. And then I have this question, because I am not sure I understand co-ops where the thing you are sharing gets used up. Clothes are a persistent object that can be shared. But once I use electricity, I cannot reuse it or share it. So I am confused about how a utility co-op would work, beyond shared ownership of the labor. Is the thing itself something we think about differently in a co-op?
From the room · I used to operate a space, and I am curious about the entities, the actual legal structures people set up for pooling, so that people feel they are part of something, that they are protected, that they have real ownership, rather than depending on something that might be a community pop up and could simply disappear. When I used to ask lawyers about that, they were all very discouraging.
Ben · So the system itself is not supporting the creation of cooperative economic models in the way it is supposed to.
From the room · We were thinking about the examples given. They came almost exclusively out of economic and political disenfranchisement. So what is the interest today? Is it economic?
Ben · Do you have an intuition about what it might be for you?
From the room · Social disenfranchisement.
From the room · We talked about sharing resources in our buildings, and how people take things and do not return them. How do you account for that, or create an environment where people are more responsible for the shared items?
Ben · Responsibility for the commons, as a challenge.
From the room · One resource to share: the New York City Department of Small Business Services has an office for worker cooperative business development. They have services on how to start a worker cooperative, and on how to transition an existing business into one. So there is structure out there that can help support this.
From the room · There is also something called the New York City Network of Worker Cooperatives.
From the room · I grew up in a big farm family in a rural place. We composted, and when somebody was doing something, everybody else came over to help out. That was the norm. Then I moved to New York City, and I found community again. The challenge might be making this the norm again, and not the exception.
Ben · I am noticing there is very little chocolate left. Did anyone not get any?
Joseph · One thing about the chocolate. It has gone around once, and in Korea there is a saying that means do not look at it with your eyes. You know that last piece at Thanksgiving, it gets cold and everyone at the table is just looking at it. Once it has gone around once, if you see it, take it.
Ben · We can send it around one more time for whoever wants it.
From the room · Bikes came up. I am in some bike negotiations with my neighbors right now about borrowing each other's bikes, and I was thinking we could just share five bikes between the five of us and leave them all on the same combination, instead of individually negotiating every time.
From the room · We talked a bit about the commodification of care, how everyone outsources massage or movement care, and how there is a paywall in New York on access to everything. Some of that is the cost of space, and honoring people and their resources. But there are physical, tangible care things we can learn how to do and share with each other, so we have easier access. A small example: my new roommate had really bad period cramps the other day, and she had never had anybody manually support her back and stretch her and care for her in that pain. I was able to do that for her, and she said she wished a massage therapist was there. A massage therapist is not in your home when you are dealing with pain and cannot leave. Your roommate is. And the next step is that she wants to learn how to do it so she can do it for me. These are little tools we can share, instead of something we have to pay for to have someone touch us and tend to our bodies.
Ben · We will do two more.
From the room · We were discussing an organization I came across at an event in the summer. The founder talked about how you might want to own a brownstone one day and would not be able to do it on your own salary. So she finds people and pairs them up. A three or four unit brownstone whose mortgage you cannot afford alone becomes affordable if you buy it with two other people. The other important thing she discusses is having a prenup. You come up with the agreement beforehand, so you know you cannot be in my living area after nine or ten, and you talk about sharing childcare and cooking too. That event is part of why I wanted to come to this one.
Ben · One last one.
From the room · I have been studying regenerative economics, and something came up a few weeks ago: energy is not included in many of the mainstream economic models we use today, meaning the amount of energy it takes to produce something. If we replace everything with robots, are we actually accounting for the energy it takes to maintain the robots? Same with alternative business models like a cooperative, the energy it takes not only to run it but to sustain it, and the impetus needed to create it in the first place. It is a lot easier to order the drill off of Amazon. It is a lot easier to ignore your neighbor. It is easier than the energy it takes for me to go and knock on your door when my energy is already spread so thin. For me this comes back to values. How much do you want to get to know the other person? It is not about the drill. It is about checking in on another human. I want to know they are doing okay. Maybe they will borrow a drill sometime. I am not going to them only when I have a need. My need is to make sure the person across from me is doing okay. That is the most important thing to me.
Ben · I love this little moment where we get the chance to hear what is in the room. There is a desire to share more. There is a desire to find ways of making it work. Some pockets of the room do not know what the next step is, and other people here have more knowledge, and that is what is so exciting about this group.
And that final point about energy is a real question to challenge ourselves with. At the end of the day, the energy needs to come from somewhere. Are we willing to put it in, or are we going to keep extracting it from a system that already makes things easy and convenient enough for us to ignore the humans around us? So that is maybe a little opportunity for introspection.
When Jessica and I were planning this session, I thought it would be really cool to start us off with the history, with how other groups in much more disenfranchised settings were able to surmount all of it and create lasting structures that could shift the paradigm for themselves and their communities. Where I wanted her to take it next is more into the present day. What are examples of cooperatives today? How are they operating? What are the challenges, and where do we go from there? So for the next twenty minute block, Jessica is back and I get out of the way.
Jessica · Before I go on, a disclaimer. I am a co-op historian, a co-op advocate and a co-op educator. I am not a technical assistance provider. Some of the questions that came up in the room need one, and a few of you already named good places to start.
There are a lot of good co-op lawyers. CUNY Law School has a law clinic with lawyers who know co-op work. Fordham has a community development law clinic that does too. There is now a whole new system of co-op community loan funds under a national cooperative network, and here in New York City you have The Working World. Those are technical assistance providers and funders with non-extractive financing, especially for worker ownership, and for other co-ops as well, housing co-ops included. There is also a nonprofit that helps tenants take over their buildings, works out with them how to buy them, and then teaches them how to rehab each of their own units so they can do it all affordably. They know housing co-op conversion and financing too. So there are actually a lot of resources out there.
If what you want is affordable housing and co-op housing, those co-op lawyers in town are the people to talk to. They have been doing it for thirty years or so, and they are good at it. They help people start with nothing and end up with a housing co-op.
From the room: Are there lawyers to talk to about starting a co-op upstate?
Jessica · There might be. The local funds are not there yet, but there are probably university extension programs that would know, Cornell and the like. I am not the expert on that one.
One of the reasons I did not become a technical assistance provider is that I am a political economist and a professor, so I try to stay in my lane a little bit. I am really excited that you all want to know more. I will warn you, Ben, that you probably want somebody after me. I motivate people at the beginning of the conversation. You need other people who can land it. If any of you have recommendations, let us know and we will put another thing together.
Jessica · So, contemporary Black co-ops. I have less than twenty minutes and I can go on forever, so let us start with municipal policies. I forgot to put New York City on the slide, but somebody already brought it up, and New York City is doing really interesting things with worker co-ops.
I was looking at two Black mayors. Marion Barry in Washington DC in the 1980s, before he imploded, when he was actually a mayor of the people, had a fascinating co-op program. He built co-op development into the mayor's office, got a little money to co-ops, and he intended DC to be a demonstration city for cooperative development. At least nine new food co-ops were started in the DC area in the 1980s, and about forty housing co-ops, and several co-op housing federations, and some worker co-ops.
Then Chokwe Lumumba, elected mayor of Jackson, Mississippi in 2013 on a platform to make Jackson a co-op city. What he meant by that was encouraging co-op formation, making sure co-op education was happening at least once or twice a year, and converting some of the municipally owned services like sanitation into worker co-ops. He died in his second year in office, and he did not have control of the city council in his first two years either, so the whole vision never got in place. He did help found a group called Cooperation Jackson, which still exists there and is still doing co-op development and co-op education.
Jessica · In the 1990s there were two interesting worker co-ops out of the Ocean Hill-Brownsville Tenants Association. The first, in 1990, was the Central Building Fedayeen Construction Company, a worker co-op to provide decent jobs for local construction workers. I do not know Brooklyn geography well enough to tell you where that is from here. East of here, I am told.
Two years later, in 1992, the same tenants association started their own worker-owned security company to do the security for their housing complex. They had help from the Nation of Islam with the training. About 20 percent of the 42 worker-owners had been incarcerated or were in recovery. So you get tenant associations, empowerment, and worker co-ops created to do the things that need doing in their own area, to make things more livable and to make sure the members have jobs.
Then quality jobs in work that gets called unskilled: Cooperative Home Care Associates in the South Bronx, started in 1985 by a social service agency to create decent jobs and provide a needed service in an impoverished community. Black and brown home care workers, mostly Latina and African American women, organized into a worker co-op. It is the largest worker co-op in the United States, and it has been the largest for twenty years. Almost 2000 employees now, 70 percent of them owners. Seventy-five percent of the employee-owners had previously been dependent on public assistance.
Think about what home care usually is. People do not always get even a forty hour week, and sometimes they work eighty hours, with very little protection and very low pay. They do not get the training they need, they do not get holidays or vacation time, and they are not unionized. Cooperative Home Care provides all of that. It is unionized, with health care, vacation time and retirement plans, above average wages, and guaranteed full-time hours wherever possible. They started their own nonprofit training subsidiary, and their motto is high quality home care and high quality jobs. The worker co-op is the high quality job, and the training is what they give their members.
The training also moves people up: home aide to certified nurse aide to LPN to RN, if they want it, and into the management of the co-op if they would rather not stay in home care, which is grueling work. So you can grow in the company as well as own it, and turnover is low.
They have also done policy advocacy, city and state, in coalition with the for-profit nursing and home care organizations, to get New York City and New York State to raise the Medicaid and Medicare rates for home care. That means all home care workers get a certain base, which means the living wage they pay their own member owners stays competitive against the whole industry, and the high quality training they provide keeps their people in demand and still affordable for customers.
They have also been fantastically profitable. When I first started studying them, the entry fee was $1,000, which sounds like a lot, but you could take it out of your wages in instalments, so people paid it over time. By the 1990s they were successful enough to pay annual dividends on membership equity of 25 percent. You put in a thousand and you get $250 a year, every profitable year, which was almost every year. In four years you have your money back and your thousand dollars is still invested in the company. These are home care workers who had contingent work, who could be fired at any minute, who never had anything, and now they are in the union with all of that, and dividends coming in for the work they do.
They also started a second co-op specialising in disability home care, because they recognized that was another area of need.
Jessica · Now, drivers needing more protection and more control. My first example is from the 1970s: the Apex Taxi Cab Cooperative, which began in January 1973 in Milwaukee with thirty new cabs. Black taxi drivers owning their own taxi company, and their competitive advantage was that they were willing to take passengers to any part of the city, unlike the white cab companies. That was also their demise. After eighteen months of relatively successful operation, the insurance company decided they were going into bad neighborhoods and were too much of a risk, and quadrupled the premium. They could not afford the insurance and that was the end of it. Still a great idea, and an important model.
Now there is The Drivers Cooperative in New York. The Co-op Ride app launched in 2021. Members make 8 to 10 percent more on each trip than on Uber and Lyft, profits go back to drivers as dividends, and the decision making is democratic. There are sibling co-ops in other cities, and the model came from a union cab company in Madison, Wisconsin. The important part is the software. They are trying to keep the software in the hands of the drivers and their riders, so the money keeps recirculating between drivers and riders instead of leaving for an outside company.
Worker rights and deindustrialization: New Era Windows in Chicago. It started as a union drive and then a fight, because the company was going to move to Mexico and take the retirement fund with it. They did sit-ins and demonstrations to demand the fund back, and eventually realised that if they bought the business they could get the fund and convert the business to a worker co-op. After two or three occupations between 2009 and 2012, they bought it.
I met one of the co-founders of that co-op on a bus at a worker conference in Mexico City, and he told me the story of how they moved the equipment. A moving company wanted $40,000 to move that heavy machinery, which they could not afford, so they decided to do it themselves. They rented trucks, spent a week working out how to pack and move everything, got their friends and family, and moved it all into another building where the rent was about half of what they had been paying. Their union helped, but their first union did not understand enough about co-ops, so about five years in they changed to a union that could help them more with the co-op model.
Climate change, and green businesses that are worker co-ops. I am on the board of Green Worker Cooperatives, which is struggling at the moment, but for fifteen years we were one of the major trainers for worker co-ops in the New York City network. The idea was to support people doing green jobs: composting, recycling, organic food, vegan and vegetarian food, even things like doula services, and photography done ecologically. You get the climate and sustainability part and the good jobs part at once.
Then a fun one, on environmental justice. Toxic Soil Busters in Worcester, Massachusetts, a youth co-op. It was founded by fifteen and sixteen year olds who were worried that their younger siblings were getting lead poisoning from playing in the backyards. Worcester is on brownfields, and a lot of the old housing has lead paint on it, so the runoff was going into the lawns, and the younger kids were playing in those lawns. These fifteen and sixteen year olds decided they had to do something about it. They joined an environmental justice group, started learning about worker co-ops at a nonprofit that let them meet there, trained themselves in how to test soil for lead and how to do lead abatement landscaping, and started their own lead abatement landscaping co-op.
Then they realised that people did not even understand the problem, so to get customers at all they had to explain it. They took up storytelling, and then they stepped into video production. They were able to buy themselves video equipment, and they had a video studio in their office, so they could make their own materials telling people why lead matters, what can be done about it, and why they should hire them.
I was at a conference with some of them years ago, talking about what it felt like to be business owners at their age. The funny part, they said, was that on weekends and after school they were running their own business, making money decisions, doing lead abatement, taking samples to the lab and reading the results, and then in class they still had to raise their hand to go to the bathroom.
Another one is Food From the 'Hood, out of Los Angeles, in the 1990s. They started a school garden right after the 1992 uprising, trying to help rebuild their community, and realised they could sell the produce at a farmers market and also give food away to homeless people in the neighborhood. Then they took a business class at their high school and realised they could add value to the produce they had, so they decided to make salad dressing. They named the dressing after the co-op, organized as a co-op, and learned how to run and manage a business. They could not sell enough salad dressing outside the school gates, so they looked at their options, and guess what had just started in those days. Amazon. They sold their salad dressing through Amazon in those first years of Amazon.
They also knew they were a student co-op and some of them were going to graduate, so they voted to save half the profits for college scholarships, and over the first ten years they distributed about $170,000. And because they were students, they knew they needed to replace themselves, so they started a program to teach the middle schoolers how to take care of the garden and how to take over the business, so that when those kids moved up to the high school they could replace the graduating seniors. The high school then started a college prep program, because it now had students with money and with aspirations for college. You see my drift: all the different connections, starting from agency, and all the spillover effects of what a co-op can do.
Jessica · A couple more. One of the fastest growing parts of the co-op movement right now is food co-ops, and Black food co-ops in particular. Gem City Market in Dayton. Detroit People's Food Co-op. Central Brooklyn Food Co-op, which I do not think has opened yet, but they have been organizing to be a food co-op for a while now. And Fertile Ground in North Carolina, which now runs a Black-led caucus that goes to all the wider food co-op meetings to take up Black co-op issues specifically.
Another youth one is Gangstas to Growers in Atlanta. That one is also about justice-involved young people and how to keep them from going back into the system, and it does it through food. It is a social enterprise with a community garden, training young people in horticulture and in how to run the garden, and also helping them start worker co-ops. Their first worker co-op is Sweet Sol, a hot sauce company, making hot sauce from some of what they grow in the garden and then selling it.
My last one is about previously incarcerated people, this time adults, mostly women. The problem is simply that it is very hard to get a job if you are previously incarcerated. One of the answers is in Chicago: Chi Fresh Kitchen, which started in 2020, during COVID. It turned out in some ways to be a good time for them to start, because they are a meal prep company and they were set up to do prep and distribution to people who were homebound. They had the idea before COVID and before the lockdown, and although that was probably the worst time to start most businesses, it was a great time to start theirs. There was a huge need for healthy, well made food delivered to your home. These are mostly Black women, mostly returning citizens, previously incarcerated women who needed jobs and could not find them anywhere else. A co-op development organization gave them training and helped them start the co-op, and they have been wildly successful.
What do I mean by wildly successful? They are considered one of the largest Black woman owned businesses in Chicago. They are grossing $2.8 million, which is the projection for this year. They own their own building, a fully rehabbed commercial kitchen of 6,125 square feet. Two years ago they realised their members had a housing problem too, so they bought a building and created a housing co-op, and last year they created a second housing co-op for more of their members. They are also starting a snack food co-op, so they can add snack foods to their meals. And they started a nonprofit called Volts, a holding company that holds all the real estate, does the back office services for the worker co-ops, helps manage the housing co-ops, and does co-op development, looking for more co-ops that could give previously incarcerated people good jobs and housing. Those of us who study worker co-ops with returning citizens know they need wraparound support. Giving somebody a good job in a worker co-op is not quite enough on its own.
So let me wrap up with the important components. The education part, internal study circles, and public education and publicity. Adequate resources, management training and financing, which came up here tonight. There is a growing number of resources: more community development financial institutions that know about co-ops, more local co-op loan funds around the country. We are getting better at the capitalization. We are sort of okay on education, but we definitely need a lot more of it, and a lot more public knowledge, so that people know these options are out there, that these things work, and how they work. Human energy and enthusiasm, which somebody already said, to keep these things going. Solidarity and a sense of trust among members. Local control as well as inter-cooperation, so that people understand that they own and control these companies, and what the responsibilities of that are as well as the privileges. The importance of reaching and incorporating youth. And the importance of recognizing women's leadership.
And then the other benefits, which I think all of these examples illustrate. Co-ops recirculate resources. They employ community members and they give back to community. They let us leverage pooled resources into further resources. They require some level of transparency, because they are democratic organizations, and they depend on democratic participation, joint ownership and joint decision making. They promote leadership. And they anchor economic activity in a community. Thank you very much.
Ben · Wow. I guess that was a lot of examples, and I love it.
Jessica · I had to cut that three times to get it down to our fifteen minutes, so there is a lot of other material I could have talked about.
Ben · Which I love. It is one thing to hear about the theory. What you have done is show that so much of this is possible, and that it is happening all around us. It might just not be visible to us, but it is there.
Ben · It is one thing to hear the theory. What your presentation did was show that so much of this is already possible, already happening all around us, and just not visible to us. For those who are a little shy, you can drop questions into the app and I will be monitoring them over here.
My own question first. We are in a room full of people who are already sold on the idea, who already think co-ops are important and valuable and want to participate more. What is the first step for this group, which I am going to guess is somewhat upper middle class, educated, with a lot of potential optionality? Is it joining something? Is it starting something? Is it gathering friends together and learning about it?
Jessica · It is all those things. First of all, you already took the first step, because you are here. You decided you were interested in this topic and you came and you participated. That is the first step.
The second step depends on whether you want to be an ally, or whether there is something in your own life that cooperative economics would help with. If you are an ally, there is a lot you can do. Donate money to the co-op loan funds I talked about. Support the movements around the country working on the enabling laws, because some states do not have good ones. New York State actually has really good co-op laws. Some states do not. Right now we are trying to get a bill passed in California to allow incarcerated workers to start co-ops while they are in prison. I have been doing research on that, and I have been consulting with some guys in San Quentin who are trying to start a food co-op while they are inside, and they found a group to help them sponsor a law that would let them do it legally under California law. There are ways to support that kind of activity. And become a customer of the co-ops that already exist here in New York City. Learn more about what is already out there.
If you want to do something in your own life, in your own sphere, then call a group together. Talk to people with a similar interest, pull a group together, start to study together, bring in outside information or outside technical assistance where you need it, share readings. A lot of groups have started as book clubs. Start reading a book, or articles, and talking about it.
The model is so flexible that I have not found an economic issue where there is not a co-op model that would work for it. As long as you have the vision of the values and the kind of non-exploitative collective relations you want to have, you can work out which co-op model fits, or how to tweak one. And New York City especially has fantastic co-op lawyers who can help you figure out how to do it legally once you tell them what you want to do.
When I say there is no industry you cannot use a co-op for, I mean it. There was a co-op in San Francisco, exotic dancing, strippers, where the dancers and the bouncers and the janitors were all owners together. It was a peep show, the Lusty Lady. The rent went up after about ten years and they had to disband, but they had a good run and it was a really fantastic model. That is what I mean. I cannot think of an interest where you could not work something out. Some things we just need to get rid of. The rest of it, we can find a creative, collective, cooperative model that will work. So find people who are already doing it, find people with similar interests to you, and keep talking about it.
Ben: Who should not think about starting a co-op? It is clearly not going to be easy. What are the attributes that would tell someone to disqualify themselves from this before they even start?
Jessica · Technically, anybody who is willing to put in the time and who is not greedy. This is not the model if you want to become a multimillionaire. It is not a model for someone who wants to gouge people and take whatever they can get.
I was at a business dinner once, sitting next to a banker, and I was telling him about my work, and he said, oh, I would never share money with anybody, I make millions. And I said, you know what, you are right. You do not need to do it. I do not even care about you, you are not the kind of person I worry about. But I was also in a hot tub with a guy at a birthday party, a middle manager, and he was asking how it works, and I was talking about exploitation and why the managers and the owners should walk off with all the money and not pay anybody, and he actually got interested. So, no greedy people allowed.
And you have to be willing to put in the work. It is not a fast turnaround. Co-ops tend to have better longevity precisely because it takes time and people's real commitment to make it work. If you are in it to do something inside a year, it is not for you either. But even if you do not think you have enough time, I do not think time is the real issue. I think it is the commitment. I have known a lot of people who were way too busy to imagine they could help start a co-op, and they committed to it because it made sense, and in the end it made their lives easier, even though at the beginning they had to work out how to fit it in.
Ben · So if you are greedy or you have commitment issues, do not start a co-op. Questions from the room. Hand up over there, and introduce yourself.
From the room: Do you have suggestions for how to unlearn it, the capitalist part?
Jessica · How do we unlearn the capitalist individualist greediness we have. That is a great question. One answer is learning by doing. And I do believe in starting small. Some of the co-ops I studied literally started as a buying club, which is much smaller than a co-op grocery store. In a buying club you just have a few people, you pool the money, somebody goes and buys in bulk with the money you have. That starts you thinking differently. It starts you thinking about how much money you want to pool, what you want to do with it, what responsibility you want to take in the group.
There is nothing wrong with starting small, and sometimes small is much better, because people get to know each other better and get to understand their own tendencies and what they need to purge or develop. And the small victories, especially if we claim them, can be really powerful.
That is the other thing. We all already do everyday acts of economic solidarity, but we do not claim it, we do not always think about it, and we usually do not name it. We borrow from each other, we lend to each other, we do all kinds of things already. So how do you turn it up, just a little? How do you start doing it with a group of people and start learning how to make decisions, how to come to a decision when nobody agrees? We need to take the time to train ourselves, and that is where the trial and error comes in. Do it on a small thing in your building or at your job, and then build up from there, with people who are also committed to learning by doing and figuring it out as they go along, and to getting training. There are a lot of people out there now who are willing to train us in how to talk to each other, how to solve problems, and how to embrace conflict so we can move forward. A lot of people are willing to train us, if we are willing to learn it.
From the room: A lot of the examples you gave had a lifetime of ten or fifteen years. On that question of longevity, is there some lesson in what the ones that lasted did?
Jessica · I tried to give you those lessons learned on what makes a co-op strong, so the co-ops that did not do a good job of all that. I am sorry, I should just list it again, but I am getting a little tired.
Succession planning really mattered. Sometimes a co-op does not really orient the new people, and the new people do not have the same enthusiasm or the same history, so they start to take the co-op for granted and do not keep up that level of commitment. Sometimes it is the sabotage I mentioned, where they could not get insurance or could not get a line of credit from a bank. Some of the co-ops did implode because they never figured out how to do co-op management, how to let people disagree, how to get people to make decisions. One of my friends was in a worker co-op that finally made a profit after about five years, and they almost went under because they were fighting about what to do with it. All the co-op lawyers I know now, when they help you create your bylaws, make you figure that out before you make the first profit. So it is not a fight any more. It is already built in, this much back into the business, this much out in dividends.
Anticipating things matters. I love Food From the 'Hood because they literally anticipated it. We are graduating, so we are going to need new people in the co-op. They deliberately went and started training new people and made sure they had people who could replace them.
And some of the co-ops are long lived. Cooperative Home Care Associates is forty years in already. Another co-op just invited me because it is their fiftieth anniversary. Some of my examples are short, a year or two or five years, some are five to twenty years. Five to twenty years is really good. The honest truth, as an economist, is that when you compare the lifespan of co-ops to small businesses, co-ops come out ahead. Small businesses only last one to five years. But we always think co-ops should be better than they are, and if they are not, we count it against them. Then we think about the huge conglomerates and multinationals that last for hundreds of years. Why do they last? Because they are gouging, everybody at the top is making huge profits. Regular small businesses, mom and pops, do not last that long. They have lots of challenges, and co-ops actually do better, but we do not always see it that way. So that is one thing to put in perspective. And the other is to prepare ourselves better, to imagine as much as we can what the problems and the pitfalls are going to be, and either put it in the bylaws legally or handle it through training.
The strongest co-ops I know, especially the worker co-ops, pay people to do the training and pay people to attend a board meeting, because they want to value people's time, if they have the money to do it. Or they rotate how much responsibility people have, so it is not all on one or two people. You do not have to have everybody at one meeting. You can do committee meetings where the decisions get made at committee level, so not everybody has to be at the main one. It is thinking through all the things that could be barriers and working out how to avoid them or mitigate them.
Ben: So the education and the trust building have to be consistently reinforced. And one thing that comes to mind is that even if the co-op ends, I am guessing it leaves people mostly better than it found them, more than a business might. There is a whole relational gain to the entire thing.
Jessica · Capacity, skills. There are people whose co-op failed who went and started another one, or went on and took leadership somewhere else. I am so glad you said that, because usually it is the first thing I say. I never really talk about failure, because even if the business fails, the whole process of doing it was a win, and everybody comes out better.
From the room: Do most co-ops form out of a need people have, and is there a benefit to forming one preventatively? And do we actually need companies to exist for a hundred years? We pooled resources cooperatively during the pandemic and it went dormant once it was not needed any more, and maybe that is okay.
Jessica · I think you are right. I cannot remember whether I write this in my book or not, but the Chesapeake Marine Railway and Dry Dock Company, which Du Bois introduced me to through his writings, lasted eighteen years. It integrated the union, and all of the employees and employee owners got other jobs when it disbanded. He called it a failure. I refuse to call it a failure, because doing what they did between 1865 and 1883 is incredible, and integrating the union so that everybody still had a job afterwards, good jobs and control over their work, is incredible. He wanted it to last longer, and his analysis was that they did not really know how to run a co-op that well, so the management fell down.
But yes, I agree with you. Sometimes they serve their purpose and they are done. Sometimes it is sad, when their purpose is not finished and somehow they go under or they are sabotaged, and that is the stuff we should fight against. I do not think we should cling to the idea that it has to last for ages. It needs to do what it was supposed to do.
The definition of a co-op is a values-based business that addresses a community need with a collective solution. So technically a co-op is about addressing an economic need with a community, and not trying to be profit maximizing. You do not go into it to make the profit, you go into it to address a community need, or to provide affordable high quality goods and services. That is why a lot of the examples address a need. But I think you can count anticipating needs, or trying to build people's capacity to own and run their own stuff, as a reason to start a co-op. It does not have to be an immediate survival need. It does have to be a social purpose.
From the app, read by Ben: In this moment we have a huge rise of democratic socialism, this whole wing of the DSA coming through. How does that differ from cooperative economics, in principle and in practice? And as we think about the future, what opportunities are emerging that we should be anticipating?
Jessica · Socialism is different from cooperativism because socialism is top down. It depends on government support, government policy, government legislating these things, and there is nothing wrong with that. But for me the co-op model is stronger, because most co-ops are bottom up. Not always, some co-ops are legislated or come from the top down. From my studies, the things that bubble up from the bottom, that start at the grassroots with grassroots people deciding it, educating themselves to make it work, doing it, and then demanding that the government support it and provide the policies and the resources, that is a much stronger model. It is almost that cliche about teaching someone to fish, not quite as paternalistic as that, but the same idea. People build the capacity, do it, try it, say what they need, and then we develop policy and government support based on what we are already doing and what we say we need, rather than legislating it and saying, okay everybody, form a co-op. I do not mean to put it that starkly, but that to me is the difference.
On the other hand, it does not hurt to have democratic socialists in power, because they do tend to be more interested in these kinds of projects. If we start demanding things, we at least have people who are willing to say, yes, let us put resources into it, oh, you need that new policy, let us do it. So they can go hand in hand, and they do. But for me, just having a socialist government say let us do this is not going to be good enough, or long lasting enough.
Ben · So the future is in our hands, essentially, regardless of which government is in power. Thank you so much for taking the time. You survived the twenty minute timer. I also want to say that Jessica is here for free, giving up her time on a Saturday night, which is great for us and really generous on her part.
Ben · This is the part of the evening I actually find really fun. We are going to step away from cooperative economics as a topic and make room for community announcements. I said a version of this earlier and I mean it: one of the core reasons we hold these events is not the content. The content is the excuse. You are here to find each other. I think a foundation for building trust is just spending more face-to-face time with people around shared interests and goals. So if you are hosting an event, putting something together, working on something, running an experiment you want to try, say it out loud to the room. It does not have to relate to co-ops. We are going to move fast, because Jessica is getting tired and we want to give her a chance to be part of the book signing. Who has something to holler at us?
From the room · I have been involved in a lot of different co-ops, and everything you said is true. It is the way to go, with or without government. I work with a coalition of nonprofit groups devoted to collective, community based climate action, and the NYC 2030 District is one of them. We are going to be working with a group called Good Standing, which is a platform for collective action. Climate is a real challenge and it is complicated, so we need ways for everybody to be involved. The programs are for anyone with a Con Edison bill. One is lowering demand at the peaks, which is what fires up the dirtiest power plants. The other is signing people up for solar, which brings clean energy in. I would love to share it through your channels at some point.
From the room · We are facilitating Action Lab #6 on Tuesday. It is called The Economics of Trust, and it is about resource pooling. We are going to come together and experiment with what it would actually take to pool our resources collectively. We have made cards out of all the different mechanisms and models we have used in workshops. The most interesting question for me is past the mechanics: why would you want to do this at all, and what has to be true for us to get value out of it and actually trust each other with it. It is here, Tuesday, around 7pm, capped at 30 people. It is less about funnelling you into one thing and more about exploring what would be interesting for you. We would love to see you there.
From the room · I am a producer and a multidisciplinary artist, and I put together most of my shows. I have an idea I am rolling out as a soft launch on December 13th, and I am open to collaborators. It is called Birdsong, and it celebrates a friend's birthday. He is an expert on the birds of New York City and an incredible musician, so we are going to have dance and live music. I want to tell the story of birds. I am looking for dancers, artists, people who like costumes, and anyone who wants to help out.
From the room · I recently decided I am going to build up my own sexuality coaching practice. I would love to connect with anybody who is on a similar road, and if anyone is further along and runs their own practice, I would love to pick their brain.
From the room · I am an art therapist, and I host offerings, and I do a lot of work on collective care and decolonized therapy, on how to deal with capitalism and everything that is going on. If that interests you, or if you have wisdom, guidance or books for me to read, I would love that. The other thing is a film I have been working on for almost ten years. Ten years ago we interviewed teenage girls about their dreams and what life was like, and we are going back now to see how the world has changed their lives and what their hopes are. We interviewed 111 girls and have been working with them ever since, from all over the world, so we want to bring together 111 people for them. There is a gathering in March, and a lot of unpaid preparation before it. We are operating on close to zero money and have been for years.
From the room: Involved how? Being interviewed, or as mentors?
From the room · Mentorship. A lot of them are interested in art but do not know where to go or how to do it. A lot of them are the first in their families to go to college. Some of them have wanted to start a school for years and have actually started the one they wanted, and are now looking for mentorship and guidance from teachers. All sorts of resources are needed. I do the matching.
Ben: Quick hands in the room. Anyone interested in being a mentor for this?
From the room: How old are the girls now?
From the room · They are 15 to 23.
From the room · My roommate and I went through a stretch this year without safe housing, and it gave us a very visceral lived experience of what that is like. Going into the winter we want to run a community drive and do on the ground care and work for people dealing with housing insecurity. It is a baby idea. If you have worked with people who need housing help, or you have organizations we should get in touch with about partnering, or you are just excited about it, come talk to us.
Ben · Let us try about two sentences each so we get all the way round, because Jessica is getting tired.
From the room · If you are interested or involved in ocean conservation education, come find me.
From the room · I am looking to buy a home upstate with five or more bedrooms and split it evenly with other people who want more trees in their lives.
From the room: How far upstate are you talking?
From the room · Around Woodstock.
From the room · My partner and I would qualify. Nicer roommates, and a big piece of property with five bedrooms. Let us talk.
From the room · I consult with a cargo bike company, and I need a paid artist or a production company to build the bikes out for the season. We did Halloween. Now imagine the holiday season, or a Thanksgiving cornucopia. So physical artists and sculptors.
From the room · I am hosting a monthly meditation gathering at a wonderful place called Anew, a community space and sustainable coffee shop with a beautiful salon they have made available for it. The first one is December 2nd, from 8:30 to 10 in the morning. Meditation, some qigong, some contemplative practice, and meeting other folks. The intention is to leave more recharged and able to do the great work.
From the room · I came down from Boston for this. I am working on a climate action platform that has turned into a tool for finding like minded people in a hyperlocal space who can build their own resilience. It shifts the story from massive top down interventions we cannot do anything about to what can happen on the ground with my neighbors right now, with more fun and social connection along the way. If any of that resonates, let us have a conversation.
From the room · I am launching a film platform called Cafe Cinema. We share revenue across the whole platform. It is an alternative to YouTube for filmmakers, for films that are past their festival run, so you can still make money on your film.
MCK · There is a book that has meant a lot to me this year, and one of the authors featured in it, Michelle Schenandoah, put together a video series and asked whether people would host gatherings so others could hear what the elders in it have to say. It is a PBS series, five episodes. We are going to watch them on the next few Sundays at Caravan of Dreams, which some of you have been to. Each episode is about 55 minutes, and afterwards we break into small groups and talk amongst ourselves and try to make sense of what we are hearing and how it relates to our lives. Michelle might be there next week. Please come join us.
Ben · Thank you all so much for coming and for being part of this little growing community. Before we break out, we are going to do the great bowl pass. All the food, the empty containers and the trash go to the front. Actually, no, pass it to the back.
For those who want a book, there are 13 copies here, so there are not that many. They are $30 each. I managed to get a bit of a discount, because it is usually about $40 on Amazon, so if you pick one up, Venmo me $30. Jessica is going to be hanging out here, signing them.
One more round of applause for Jessica. And thank you for showing up and supporting us, and for being part of this grand community experiment of coming together. As you get up, watch out for empty cans, and if you see something lying around that does not belong there, please pick it up.
We are going to take about 20 to 30 minutes for a break. We can fold the chairs up to the side and figure out what to do with them. Then, for those who want to go deeper, we break out into little topic rooms through the house, for longer conversations about what it might look like to move some of these initiatives a couple of steps forward: housing and land; tools, cars and shared stuff; food and care; shared infrastructure. After that, a warm data lab, a share back and the close. If you want to leave, there is no pressure at all, it is a Saturday night. The exits are over there. Thank you so much for coming.
Ben · This is a conversation we could all have for a much longer time. It is not something you resolve in twenty or thirty minutes with a group, so our intention is always just to plant as many seeds as possible. If you met someone you really resonated with, or there is a little thing you were tickled by, please hold on to it and see how you want to take it a bit further. I want to go through each group one at a time so we all have a sense of what is going on. And then if you did not like your group, you are totally invited to defect and go make friends with another one.
From the room · We were in food and care. Dear Crisis is such a cerebral event, and sometimes it can be really hyper-intellectual, and there is something that connects us all in a beautiful way, which is food. Some of the things we thought were important: how do we bring a sense of dignity, because if people are food insecure there is potentially a sense of shame in asking for help. And how do we learn to accept? Sometimes it is very difficult for people to accept help. We can be desperately in need and not willing to accept care. So how do we bring that dignity and love and respect into food, into the sharing of it and the receiving of it?
An interesting intersection was that we had two healthcare professionals in the group, so the importance of mental health came up. You have a bad day and you eat a pint of ice cream or a bag of chips. We talked about one holistic idea of health, where mental health plays such a big part in our physical health and in what we eat. The big takeaway was to keep having these gatherings, to keep finding ways to share food, and to be respectful and mindful of one another while we do it.
I should say we talked about it in a broader sense than co-ops. We tried to tie it to what co-op opportunities exist, but we ended up talking from personal and professional experience rather than about building a food co-op. The co-ops I know best are food co-ops, and I think for a lot of you they might be the most familiar ones too. What a beautiful way to show care and love to other people, by taking the time to eat with them. Thank you for sharing the meal today.
From the room · I am going to talk about shared infrastructure, which was the least defined group, and I think our outcome was also very not defined. We talked about what it is like to be at a party where the structure of the party is not conducive to the way you want to be in relationship with other people. Not this event. We talked about different cultural norms in different countries and communities, and the scariness of knocking on your neighbor's door. Someone shared slipping notes under people's doors saying join my WhatsApp group chat, to create a house chat in the apartment building, which was super cool.
Infra is below, so infrastructure is the structure below. It could be a technology like WhatsApp or Couchsurfing, or it could be the design of an event. We would not be having certain conversations if it was not for the infrastructure of these breakout rooms and the way that was structured. One of the through lines was who benefits and who does not benefit from shared infrastructure. A whole apartment group chat: is that benefiting the landlord, and in what ways might it not be? What are the incentive structures that guide the way we build and design infrastructure, at different scales?
Sometimes doing something really small is just easier, because you do not need to think about it. Generosity can come from the fact that it is actually harder to be greedy. If you do not have to count the pennies someone owes you from a meal, it is easier to say do not worry about it. There are cultures where that extends so far that you think, I cannot believe that person just gave this thing away, because they were in a mode of abundance. So we talked a lot about cultural and social infrastructure, and about how we have agency to design an event, a space, an experience, a tool, that changes the way people act inside it.
Jochen · For tools, cars and stuff, we had a pretty lively conversation. It went around tools, cars and stuff, but also baby showers and some other topics. A couple of things that stood out for me. Jeremy, who had to leave early, reminded us that in rural communities it is much more common for people to share things. He described people who live up the mountain, who leave the keys in the car and tell everyone, if you need a car, come by, pick it up, return it. It is just much more normal to share in other settings. Here in the city there is some stigma around it, that if you cannot afford things and need to borrow, maybe there is stigma associated with that.
Rob mentioned there is a website, Shareable, with blueprints for starting a shared-stuff co-op or group, templates you can just use. And given that many people here in New York live in co-op or condo buildings, or buildings with other units, it may not be so difficult to think about what can be shared with people in the same building, and to start from there, rather than figuring out whether it is the entire neighborhood. There are units of people that are more than just one apartment. Some things are easier to share than others, the things you do not need all the time, where if you do not have them for a few days the world does not end.
From the room · A lot of it comes down to trust, and to how a group is able to trust each other or not.
Jochen · And you may want some way by which people actually enter the group. You do not want people belonging to it just because they moved into a building. You want some way of figuring out, okay, I trust this person, because of an introduction, or some way by which they really enter the group.
From the room · Housing and land. We realized at the end that we were not the most action-oriented, but we covered a few different topics. One was that COPA was recently passed, which makes it easier for cooperatives. The Community Opportunity to Purchase Act. Nonprofits and community land trusts can purchase buildings that are being foreclosed on, we think. We need to do some more research. But it passed a couple of weeks ago. And the other thing to advocate for is the Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act. So COPA and TOPA are two different housing moves.
For myself, because I had an actual vision of a specific place, we went into that, and into the different ways it could look when it is not just a needs-based thing where people are going through a need, but desires and wants. What does that look like, and how it may be fertile ground for more conflict, or for more desire, because you have the privilege for it. Whereas Black people in the late 1800s were just trying to survive. So we talked about some of those nuances.
From the room · We talked about lifestyles a little bit. A lot of people have weekend houses upstate and leave the city to go to nature. What would it mean to have a massive ten-bedroom house upstate and share one apartment in New York, so a bunch of people live together somewhere with more trees and share a room here? Where can we share land? If land is owned by someone, can we still use it for other hobbies or other purposes?
Ben · One of the things I was thinking about is that so much of the goodwill and the desire for us to be in community and to have collective ownership of things does not really get seen. A lot of it happens invisibly. One of the hopes is that the more we speak about these things, the more we give them voice, the more we talk about what we want and bring it into spaces, the more chance they have of being discovered, and of us finding the resources to conspire to make that thing possible.
So a general invitation: keep thinking about this stuff, do not let the topic die when you leave the room. If there is someone you felt connected to, keep playing with that. And if you struggle with accountability, go find a study partner in this group. There are a lot of people here who want to dive deeper.
One thing we are trying to do differently. Until now all of our metacrisis salons have been ad hoc topics pulled from different places. Over the next couple of months we are hoping to make cooperative economics the general theme for the next three salons, and to focus on it in the action labs and workshops too. So if you have an idea or something you want to prototype or workshop, let us know. There is one person we are talking to right now who specializes in converting small businesses into cooperatively owned, worker owned businesses, and we are thinking of doing something with her. I asked her what her number one need is, and she said we just need more people who know more small businesses who are interested in having this conversation.
Erik Forman is someone in our community who started the Drivers Cooperative that Jessica shared, and they want to scale to a million riders. They think not enough people know about it. For their technology, not having enough riders means people wait longer, so they get worse service. So they essentially have a marketing problem, and their entire team is volunteer-based. We were talking to them about what an interesting collaboration might look like, to support what they are doing while we get to learn how it works. There is a natural exchange in that. Of course we also have the lab on Tuesday with Rob, which focuses on collective pooling: what does it look like to pool a bunch of resources together and decide where that money goes, and what would that structure be? On behalf of someone else, on behalf of a community, looking outwards or inwards? If we start practicing this, we get a better idea of what these things could look like and feel like.
One of the reasons I live in a 17-person community house at 40 years old, which makes me feel like a failure, is that I would like to find myself in a future living more in a village context with a group of people collectively. This is the best way to practice what that is like. What do we like about it? What do we not like? What are the greatest challenges? A lot of these conversations emerge from that space.
One last note. While Dear Crisis in its current form is not structured like a cooperative, and there is not really a business model to it, the intention behind it is cooperative in nature. The tickets are sliding scale, pay what you can. Some people pay three or five times more than the lowest paying person. Some people get it for free. There is a spirit of exchange. In so many ways there is the part where you think, I do not know how to do this because the structure does not exist, and this is the practice of just doing it and finding others who believe in the same things. We are always empowered to build that community around us. So I feel really grateful that you are all here. Thank you so much for coming out.
The four breakout rooms were recorded separately and are not reproduced here. What each one worked on is summarized on the recap page, in the Warm Data Lab section. The recording ends here.